South Australian Current Acts

[Index] [Table] [Search] [Search this Act] [Notes] [Noteup] [Previous] [Next] [Download] [Help]

CIVIL LIABILITY ACT 1936 - SECT 76

76—Assessment of motor vehicle injuries

        (1)         The regulations may, in relation to any claim, entitlement or award of damages in respect of personal injury arising from an MVA motor accident

            (a)         authorise an insurer or the nominal defendant under Part 4 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 to require a claimant to submit to an assessment or examination of a prescribed kind; and

            (b)         require that an examination or assessment be undertaken by an accredited health professional (see subsection (2)) in order to obtain advice and evidence in relation to any relevant matter; and

            (c)         specify procedures to be followed in connection with any examination or assessment, including as to the determination or selection of an accredited health professional who is to undertake the examination or assessment; and

            (d)         specify the maximum number of examinations or assessments that may be made in a particular case; and

            (e)         prescribe rules that are to be applied with respect to the determination of any injury scale value under this Act; and

            (f)         without limiting a preceding paragraph, make provision for the provision of advice or evidence about diagnosis, causation, prognosis, future requirements for treatment, care or support, or other matters that are relevant to any assessment of damages or liability in respect of the injury; and

            (g)         make provision for the preparation and furnishing of reports and other information or material, including as to the procedures or processes associated with requesting any report, document or other material, the form of any report, document or other material, and the persons to whom any report, document or other material is to be provided or made available; and

            (h)         provide for any other matter that may be relevant to assessing or determining a claim or entitlement, or making an award of damages.

        (2)         The designated Minister may establish an accreditation scheme with respect to health professionals in connection with regulations under this section.

        (3)         The accreditation scheme—

            (a)         may provide for a term or a period of accreditation, and for the suspension or cancellation of accreditation on specified grounds; and

            (b)         may specify terms or conditions of accreditation; and

            (c)         may provide for any aspect of the scheme to be administered or managed by a person or body specified by the designated Minister; and

            (d)         may provide that a person holding an accreditation, registration or other form of authorisation or status under another scheme recognised by the designated Minister will be taken to hold an accreditation under this section; and

            (e)         may be amended or substituted by the designated Minister from time to time.

        (4)         The rules that are to apply for the purpose of assessing injury scale values ("ISVs") for multiple injuries must include 1 or more provisions that adopt the following principles:

            (a)         a court must consider the range of ISVs for the dominant injury of the multiple injuries;

            (b)         in order to reflect the level of adverse impact of multiple injuries on an injured person, a court may assess the ISV for the multiple injuries as being higher in the range of ISVs for the dominant injury of the multiple injuries than the ISV that the court would assess for the dominant injury only;

            (c)         if a court considers that the level of impact of multiple injuries on an injured person is so severe that the maximum ISV for the dominant injury is inadequate to reflect the level of impact, the court may make an assessment of the ISV for the multiple injuries that is higher than the maximum ISV for the dominant injury, subject to the following qualifications:

                  (i)         the ISV for multiple injuries cannot exceed 100;

                  (ii)         the ISV for multiple injuries should rarely be more than 25% higher than the maximum ISV for the dominant injury.

        (5)         In connection with the operation of subsection (4), a dominant injury, in relation to multiple injuries, is—

            (a)         subject to paragraph (b)—the injury of the multiple injuries having the highest range; or

            (b)         if the highest range for 2 or more of the injuries of the multiple injuries is the same—the injury of those injuries selected as the dominant injury by a court assessing an ISV.

        (6)         Subsections (4) and (5) do not limit any other principle or provision that may apply under the regulations in relation to the assessment and determination of an ISV for a particular injury.

        (7)         For the purposes of the rules that are to apply for the purpose of assessing any injury scale value under a designated section (being rules that determine a substantive matter rather than prescribe a procedural matter), the relevant regulations are the regulations applying at the time of the occurrence of the relevant injury.

        (8)         If a person fails to comply with a requirement prescribed under subsection (1) in respect of a claim or proceedings made or commenced by the person—

            (a)         in the case of a claim—a person or body to which the claim has been made may decline to consider or deal with the claim while the failure continues; and

            (b)         the person is not entitled, until he or she complies with the requirement, to commence proceedings or to continue proceedings that have been commenced in respect of the personal injury.

        (9)         In addition, the regulations may—

            (a)         require an insurer or the nominal defendant under Part 4 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 to pay for the costs of examinations and assessments, and for the preparation and furnishing of reports, documents or other material, in prescribed circumstances (subject to any limits specified in the regulations); and

            (b)         limit the liability of an insurer or the nominal defendant under Part 4 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 to pay for the costs of examinations and assessments, and for the preparation and furnishing of reports, documents or other material, in connection with a claim (and any such regulation may provide that prescribed costs (if any) be borne by a claimant and will have effect according to its terms and despite a liability that would otherwise arise under Part 4 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 or any other Act or law); and

            (c)         require an insurer or the nominal defendant under Part 4 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 to make a contribution (determined in accordance with the regulations) towards the costs of the accreditation scheme established by the Minister under this section (including so that the scheme is fully-funded through the making of those contributions).

        (10)         A regulation under subsection (1)(e) may only be made on the recommendation of the designated Minister.

        (11)         Before the designated Minister makes a recommendation under subsection (10), the designated Minister must consult with—

            (a)         the Attorney-General; and

            (b)         The South Australian Branch of the Australian Medical Association Incorporated; and

            (c)         The Law Society of South Australia.

        (12)         If an association referred to in subsection (11) objects to any matter contained in a regulation under subsection (10), the designated Minister must, at the request of that association, prepare a report that—

            (a)         provides information about the consultation that has been undertaken; and

            (b)         sets out the objection that has been made (including the reasons put forward by the association for its objection).

        (13)         The Minister must cause a copy of a report under subsection (12) to be laid before both Houses of Parliament as soon as is reasonably practicable after the request is made.

        (14)         In addition, a regulation that would have the effect of changing the injury scale value applying with respect to a particular injury so that a person who suffers that injury (and no other injury) would, on account of that change, no longer have a right to damages for non-economic loss under section 52(3) and (4) cannot come into operation until the time for disallowance of the regulation has passed.

        (15)         Nothing in this section is intended to prevent or restrict a court from exercising any judicial power or from determining a matter according to law.

        (16)         In this section—

"designated Minister" means the Minister from time to time designated by the Governor by proclamation to be the designated Minister for the purposes of this section;

"designated section" means any of the following sections:

            (a)         section 52;

            (b)         section 56A;

            (c)         section 58;

            (d)         section 65;

"health professional" means—

            (a)         a registered health practitioner under the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (other than a student); or

            (b)         a person who is within a class brought within the ambit of this definition by the regulations.



AustLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback