Victorian Bills Explanatory Memoranda

[Index] [Search] [Download] [Bill] [Help]


EDUCATION AND TRAINING REFORM BILL 2006

             Education and Training Reform Bill

                          Introduction Print

                EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM


                                   General
The Bill will replace 11 Acts dealing with education and training, and also
Division 8A of Part III of the Community Services Act 1970 (which deals
with the obligations of parents to send their child to school).
The 11 Acts relating to education and training comprise the--
         ·     Education Act 1958;
         ·     Adult Community and Further Education Act 1991;
         ·     Vocational Education and Training Act 1990;
         ·     Tertiary Education Act 1993;
         ·     Teaching Service Act 1981;
         ·     Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority Act 2000;
         ·     Victorian Qualifications Authority Act 2000;
         ·     Victorian Institute of Teaching Act 2001;
         ·     Baxter Technical School Land Act 1982;
         ·     Educational Grants Act 1973; and
         ·     Education (Special Developmental Schools) Act 1976.
The Bill does not affect the individual University Acts. The Bill updates the
current legislation relating to education and training by--
         ·     removing obsolete provisions;
         ·     updating provisions and re-enacting others that are up-to-date;
         ·     inserting new provisions including principles and other reform
               matters;




                                       1
551276                                         BILL LA INTRODUCTION 8/2/2006

 


 

· grouping together provisions currently spread across a number of Acts dealing with similar subject matter; · merging, simplifying and introducing a consistent approach in those sections grouped together. Main Changes The following is a summary of the main changes to the current Acts-- · PRINCIPLES. Clauses 1.2.1 and 1.2.2 insert sets of principles. Regulations will be made to implement the principles listed at clause 1.2.1(a), (c), (e) and (f). The principles at clause 1.2.2 (2)(a), (b) and (c) are given legal effect by other provisions in the Bill, and clause 1.2.2(2)(d) will be implemented by administrative arrangements. · GOVERNMENT SCHOOLS. State schools are to be called Government schools and they must be registered as do current non-Government schools. · SCHOOL DEFINITION. There is a new definition of "school" in clause 1.1.3. It is modelled on the definition in most other States and is designed to be wider than the current section 35 of the Education Act 1958 which only covers assemblies of persons. · SCHOOL REGISTRATION CRITERIA. The criteria for the registration of schools will change from those in the current section 42 of the Education Act 1958, to prescribed minimum standards. · SCHOOL LEAVING AGE. The school leaving age is increased from 15 to 16 years of age. On turning 16, children will be able to leave school, although the vast majority continue their studies beyond that age. · RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION. The position on religious instruction in Government schools is clarified, so as to permit discussion of events or topics that involve religion, whilst maintaining the current position that religious instruction is voluntary and can only be given by accredited instructors. · HOME SCHOOLING. Parents who prefer to educate their child at home rather than sending them to school will need to seek approval for home schooling. 2

 


 

· FREE INSTRUCTION. Clause 2.2.4 provides for free instruction in Government schools to students under 20 years of age on 1 January. The current section 22(2) of the Education Act 1958 limits free instruction to "pupils" but does not define "pupils". · VOLUNTARY CONTRIBUTIONS. The position on voluntary financial contributions in Government schools is set out in clause 2.2.7 and includes guarantees against coercion or harassment as well as other safeguards. · NEIGHBOURHOOD GOVERNMENT SCHOOL. Clause 2.2.13 provides a child with the right to attend his or her designated neighbourhood Government school. · FEES AND CHARGES. Clause 2.3.6 (1)(c) enables school councils to charge parents for matters supplied to students. This is subject to clause 2.2.4 which provides for free instruction in the learning areas in Schedule 1 and is also subject to Ministerial Order. · Students aged 20 years and over may be charged fees. · COUNCILS OF GOVERNMENT SCHOOLS. The following are the main changes to the provisions on school councils-- · A council may be established for a proposed school. · Council members may receive reimbursement of reasonable expenses. · Clause 2.3.4 is new and sets out the objective of a council. · The function statement for councils is updated in clause 2.3.5 with (a), (b) and (i) being new. In particular, (a) gives a council a general power to supply or arrange for any matters for a school. · The wider and revised powers of school councils are in clause 2.3.6. In particular, sub clause (1)(d) is a new general power which enables a council to do anything necessary or convenient for meeting its objectives or performing its functions, subject to the limits expressed in clause 2.3.6(3). 3

 


 

· The delegation powers of councils have been widened at clause 2.3.15, so as to enable a council to delegate its powers to any person or body. · The school plan referred to at clause 2.3.24 will replace the current school charter that councils are required to have under the Education Act 1958. · The position of councils under the Financial Management Act 1994 is being clarified. For the future, clause 2.3.30 requires that the report of operations of the Department under the Financial Management Act 1994 is to include a summary of the information provided by councils in their annual reports. · Clause 2.3.2 (2)(c) expands the Ministerial Order making power to enable the imposition of duties on individual members of councils, to reflect the approach taken in the Public Administration Act 2004. · RSB and VQA. The Registered Schools Board (RSB) and Victorian Qualifications Authority (VQA) are abolished. Their current functions will be assumed by the new Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority (VRQA). The VRQA will also take over the Minister's current powers in the Tertiary Education Act 1993 to accredit courses in higher education and approve and authorise providers of higher education. · VRQA. The new Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority will be responsible for-- · the registration of all schools (both Government and non-Government) and students undertaking home schooling; · in relation to years 11 and 12 of schooling and in Vocational Education and Training or in further education-- · accrediting courses; · authorising providers of accredited courses; · registering qualifications; · authorising providers to award registered qualifications; 4

 


 

· in relation to higher education-- · accrediting courses; and · approving and authorising providers of higher education; · approving all providers of courses to overseas students. The VRQA's functions will result in the merger of the powers currently exercised by 3 authorities--the RSB in respect of registering non-Government schools, the VQA in respect of accredited courses and providers and the Minister in respect of higher education and overseas students in non-Government schools or in higher education. The other main changes to the current VQA provisions are-- · Clause 4.3.10 clarifies the ability of schools to be registered training organisations. · Clause 4.9.4 authorises the VRQA to disclose information to Commonwealth bodies, such as the Department of Education, Science and Training and the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs. This is necessary to enable the VRQA to manage risks associated with overseas students and other courses that involve the Commonwealth. · Clause 4.5.1 (5) amends the current section 27(5) of the VQA Act to enable the VRQA to approve a provider of courses to overseas students for up to 5 years, rather than a fixed 5 year period. This change mirrors the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 of the Commonwealth and other provisions of the current VQA Act. · Clause 4.2.3 clarifies the authority's ability to exercise its powers outside Victoria. · VLESC. The Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission is being renamed the Victorian Skills Commission. 5

 


 

· MINISTER'S POWERS AND FUNCTIONS. The Minister's powers and functions have been updated in the following areas-- · Industry Training Boards, approved training agents and bodies to advise the Minister on post secondary education will in future be established by the Minister. They are currently established by the Governor in Council. · The powers to provide education or training outside Victoria have been strengthened (ref. clause 5.2.10). · There is an express power to require financial agreements from persons receiving moneys from the State for educational purposes (ref. clause 5.2.13). This is required because of the repeal of the Educational Grants Act 1973. · Multi-sector arrangements are given special provisions (ref. clause 5.2.4). · The Minister's common law powers to do anything that is "necessary or convenient to be done in or in connection with the functions of the Minister" under the Bill or other Act is stated in clause 5.2.3, as well as clarifying the Minister's powers to determine policy, issue guidelines or seek information. · Obligations are placed on education bodies to supply information required by the Minister for the effective monitoring, development and planning of education and training (ref. clause 5.1.2). · Clause 5.2.11 updates the Minister's powers of delegation so as to provide a consistent approach across the whole portfolio and to cover all the Minister's powers under the Bill, but subject to important limitations listed in that clause. · ANTA. The repeal of the Australian National Training Authority Act of the Commonwealth and the passing of the Skilling Australia's Workforce Act 2005 of the Commonwealth necessitated various amendments to the Vocational Education and Training and Victorian Qualifications Authority provisions. 6

 


 

· IMMUNITIES FROM LEGAL ACTION. The Bill updates the immunities in the current provisions, in line with Government policy, by-- · removing the immunities for the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission, TAFE councils, Industry Training Boards, Adult Community and Further Education Regional Councils, the Adult Community and Further Education Board and the Minister and Secretary; and · inserting an immunity for members of the Merit Protection Boards and Discipline Appeals Board in respect of the Teaching Service and members of Victorian Institute of Teaching panels who hear discipline matters. · OBSOLETE ACTS. The Bill will replace the following Acts-- Baxter Technical School Land Act 1982 This Act authorised the Minister to lease part of the school's land to the Commonwealth for defence purposes, to construct certain buildings on the land and to establish a joint committee of management for the leased land. The Commonwealth owned lands adjacent to the school and it transferred those lands to the Minister in consideration of the Minister constructing certain buildings on the land and granting a lease back to the Commonwealth over the same lands. This Act is spent. Any new lease will be entered under the Minister's general power to enter leases rather than having a special Act for the purpose. The Education Grants Act 1973 specifies a capitation grant, in respect of each primary pupil and for each secondary pupil, to be paid to the school authority of a "non-government school". The Act has been overtaken by a number of developments at both the Commonwealth and State levels and is being repealed. It is being replaced by clause 5.2.13 which authorises the Minister to require any person or body to enter an agreement as a condition of receiving any State government funding. 7

 


 

Education (Special Developmental Schools) Act 1976 This Act is out of date and superfluous. It provides for long service and sick leave entitlements of members of the teaching service employed in a special developmental school. The provisions in the Act will be replaced by a Ministerial Order to the same effect. Particular provisions needing further explanation · Clause 1.1.2 provides that the Bill is to commence on a day or days to be proclaimed, but not later than 31 December 2007. This has the potential for the Bill, or parts of it, to commence more than 12 months after its Royal Assent. The reasons for the delayed sunrise date are as follows-- · There are some provisions (such as increasing the compulsory school age to 16, or the requirement for all schools to be registered) that should coincide with the start of a school year, so the sunrise date of 31 December has been selected. · The reason for selecting 2007 is to allow sufficient time to prepare regulations prescribing the criteria for the registration of all schools and home schooling and to give all persons adequate notice of the new regulations. It is expected that it will take 12 months to finalise those regulations. · Clause 2.3.15 widens the delegation powers of councils of Government schools, and enables them to delegate matters to "another person or body". The broad delegation power is intended to support different forms of school education provision which might emerge through the Capital Investment and Access Policy and under clause 5.2.4 which covers multi sector arrangements. For example, a group of schools may decide to form a federation and delegate some (or all) powers to an overarching council; two schools may form an association with a TAFE provider and thereby create a new governance body. 8

 


 

· Councils are subject to directions of the Minister, and the directions could limit the persons to whom delegations may be made. The section and directions will also provide the flexibility as circumstances change in the future without having to seek further legislative changes and to meet the requirements of school councils that need special delegation powers to meet their special circumstances. · Clause 2.1.14 provides that in any proceeding for a breach of a parent's duty to send a child to school or to receive instruction, the burden of proving the grounds of an excuse lies on the defendant. This clause reflects the current section 74F(a) of the Community Services Act 1970. The clause is not considered to involve a reversal of the legal burden of proof. The defendant, if pleading one of the excuses listed in clause 2.1.3 or any other excuse, would have to establish the facts giving rise to the excuse. If the facts of the defence are raised by the defendant, the legal burden of proof passes back to the prosecution to establish its case. · Clauses 2.3.10 and 2.4.58 provide that a school council and the Secretary must dismiss a teacher or any member of the teaching service convicted or found guilty of a sexual offence against a child. Clause 2.6.29 states that a teacher ceases to be registered by the VIT if convicted or found guilty of a sexual offence. The clauses repeat sections in the current Education, Teaching Service and VIT Acts and do not provide an appeal right against the operation of the clauses. The reason for not providing a right of appeal is because-- · a conviction or finding of guilt for a sexual offence against a child destroys the trust that must exist between a parent, the school and teacher, as well as between the Department and the employee; · the Department is charged with the care and responsibility of children, and it is inconsistent with that responsibility to employ persons found guilty or convicted of sexual offences against children; 9

 


 

· the Government has adopted a policy of zero tolerance in respect of teachers convicted of sexual offences against children; · Employees do have the right to submit that a case of mistaken identity has occurred, or that an incorrect criminal record has been received. These cases are handled administratively by internal processes; · Also the unfair dismissal laws of the Commonwealth may provide rights to employees to seek redress under that Act. · Clauses 2.6.22 and 5.3.4 authorise the Victorian Institute of Teaching and the Secretary to obtain a criminal record check without a teacher's or employee's consent. They repeat sections in the current VIT and Education Acts. The clauses may raise privacy issues, as criminal record checks can normally only be undertaken with the consent of a person. The sections in the current Acts were recently inserted to undertake criminal record checks on a number of teachers and employees who had not undergone a criminal record check before being employed or registered by the VIT. The power has been retained as it also enables the VIT and the Department to follow up any information it may receive concerning a person's background, as well as checking the validity of any information supplied by a person, or following up a criminal record check which has not disclosed offences beyond a certain date. · Clause 2.6.27 is new and permits the Victorian Institute of Teaching to suspend the registration of a teacher charged with a sexual offence against a child, after giving notice to the teacher and the opportunity to make submissions. The clause may raise issues of fairness, as a person is presumed to be innocent until convicted or found guilty. · The reason for inserting the clause is because a range of circumstances may warrant suspending the registration, or other students may need to be protected, or there is a need to uphold the reputation of the teaching profession. 10

 


 

· The circumstances that may warrant suspending the registration include where the teacher has made admissions or pleaded guilty to the offence, or where the evidence is overwhelming. · Other students may need to be protected if the teacher leaves the current employer and seeks employment at another school pending the hearing of the charges. The reputation of the teaching profession may need protection if no action is taken by the school against the teacher. · Clause 5.3.3 contains the Secretary's delegation powers. Apart from some minor limitations, they largely enable the Secretary to delegate powers to "any person". The section mirrors section 18 of the Public Administration Act 2004 which enables a public service body head (which includes the Secretary as a Department Head) to delegate powers under that Act to "any person". The reasons for providing the Secretary with a wide delegation power are-- · most of the Secretary's powers relate to employment matters, which cover those employed under the Government teaching service (under the Bill) and also administrative staff under the Public Administration Act 2004, and it is preferable that the delegation powers under both Acts be the same; · the delegation power enables the Secretary to delegate matters to other persons such as contractors with expertise, or retired officers engaged to conduct investigations or discipline enquiries. For example, a recent matter involved a delegation to a person who was retired Departmental officer and an officer of another Department. · Clause 5.10.5 repeats section 11(5) of the Teaching Service Act 1981 to enable Orders in respect of the Teaching Service to be retrospective in operation. This is necessary to enable salary increases and other entitlements to be awarded from a date before the making of the Order. 11

 


 

Clause Notes CHAPTER 1--GENERAL PART 1.1--PRELIMINARY Clause 1.1.1 sets out the purpose of the Act. Clause 1.1.2 provides that the preliminary sections of the Bill and some savings provisions come into operation on the Assent of the Act. The remaining provisions of the Bill come into operation on a day or days to be proclaimed, and that unless proclaimed beforehand come into operation on 31 December 2007. Clause 1.1.3 contains important definitions. The following definitions have been updated or are new. The definition of "Adult Community and Further Education" has been updated to reflect current practices so as to cover all secondary education for adults rather than the current "full time" secondary education for adults. "Commission" is defined to mean the Victorian Skills Commission, which will be the new name for the current Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission established under the Vocational Education and Training Act 1990. "Compulsory school age" is defined as being not less than 6 nor more than 16 years of age. The 16 years is an increase from the 15 years specified in the current section 3 of the Education Act 1958. The current compulsory school age of 15 years has applied since 4 February 1964. Increasing the age to 16 reflects the importance that a good education plays in obtaining employment as well as contributing to society, and reflects the position in other jurisdictions. On reaching 16 years of age, a child will be able to leave school, however most continue their schooling beyond their 16th birthday. "Government school" is the new term to replace "State school". The term "Government" school has been selected as it more accurately conveys the type of school, and is the term more commonly used throughout Australia. The definition of "Higher Education Award" has been considerably shortened compared to the current definition in section 9 of the Tertiary Education Act 1991. The new definition adopts the approach taken by many other States and Territories by linking the definition to relevant awards 12

 


 

listed in the Australian Qualifications Framework. This approach ensures that any changes to Higher Education Awards listed in the Framework are automatically covered under the Bill. The definition of "Overseas student" has been updated to cover students in all education institutions. The definition of "Parent" has been updated from the current definition in section 3 of the Education Act 1958 so as to cover developments under the Family Law Act of the Commonwealth which now refer to parental responsibilities. "Post compulsory education" has been simplified and updated by referring to the education of persons 16 years of age and over. It is linked to the new definition of "compulsory school age". The definition of "School" has been substantially updated from the current definition of "school" in section 35 of the Education Act 1958. The current definition in section 35 only applies to non-Government schools, but the new definition of "school" is based on the concept of persons "providing" education programs. The new definition has been designed to capture the following different types of schools-- · The traditional school--where persons gather every day for the purpose of being instructed by a teacher. · Distance education, through the internet or correspondence. · Private tutoring by a paid tutor. · Home schooling, which could involve-- · a parent or private tutor schooling children; · being at home or some other location; · (Registered home schooling is excluded from the definition of school); · Adult and Community Education providers, who provide self learning programs for students to study at home or in groups. 13

 


 

The definition of "State Register" has been updated. The State Register will include all the matters which the VRQA is required under Chapter 4 to place on the State Register. This includes registered schools, accredited courses and authorised providers. Clause 4.9.1 requires the State Register to be published on a website, so as to be publicly available. A definition of "VCAL" has been inserted. It means the Victorian Certificate of Applied Learning, and is the alternative to the VCE offered by the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority. Clause 1.1.4 is new. It states that the Act binds the Crown. This clause makes it clear that the Government, the Department and its employees must comply with the requirements of the Act or face the penalties. Clause 1.1.5 is new. It states that the Act operates outside Victoria. It is linked to other clauses which are intended to permit persons to exercise functions or powers outside Victoria, such as clause 5.2.10 (which deals with the Minister providing educational services outside Victoria), and clause 2.5.5(1)(f) for the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority and 4.2.3(2) for the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority. PART 1.2--PRINCIPLES Clause 1.2.1 is new. It states the principles underlying the enactment of the Bill. Although clause 1.2.3 states that the principles do not give rise to civil cause of action, item 8 in Schedule 5 will authorise regulations to be made-- · imposing obligations on education providers to implement the principles in clause 1.2.1(a), (c), (e) and (f); · to include the principles in clause 1.2.1(a), (c), (e) and (f) as part of the minimum standards that schools will have to meet under clause 4.3.1(6) for registration purposes; · setting out the role of the VRQA in investigating complaints from the public alleging a breach of the obligation to implement the principles under clause 1.2.1(a), (c), (e) and (f). 14

 


 

The ultimate sanction for education providers that fail to comply with their obligations under the regulations will be the cancellation by the VRQA of their registration. The principles in (b) and (e) will not be the subject of regulations, as (b) expresses in general terms a goal of access to education and (e) is linked to the rights and duties of parents under clause 2.1.1 to choose whether to enrol their child in a registered school or in home schooling. Clause 1.2.2 is new. It states the principles underlying the Government education and training system. Although clause 1.2.3 states that the principles do not give rise to civil cause of action, all persons employed in the Department will be required to implement the principles. In addition-- · the principle in clause 1.2.2(2)(a) is given legal effect by clause 2.2.10 and anti discrimination legislation; · the principle in clause 1.2.2(2)(b) is given legal effect by clause 2.2.4; · the principle in clause 1.2.2(2)(c) is given legal effect by clause 2.2.13; and · the principle in clause 1.2.2(d) will be implemented by administrative arrangements. Clause 1.2.3 is new. It states that the principles in 1.2 1 and 1.2.2 do not give rise to, nor can they be taken into account, in a civil cause of action. CHAPTER 2--SCHOOL EDUCATION PART 2.1--COMPULSORY EDUCATION Division 1--Attendance at School Clause 2.1.1 provides for compulsory schooling for children aged between 5 and 16 years. The new clause sets out 2 options for parents, namely to enrol the child at a registered school (which can be a Government or non-Government registered school), or to register the child for home schooling. The requirement to be registered for home schooling is new. Under the current sections, parents are not required to obtain approval to home school their child. 15

 


 

The new clause requires a child to attend school at all times it is open for the child's instruction, which is the approach taken in most other States. Clause 2.1.2 creates an offence for parents of children of compulsory school age who, without a reasonable excuse, fail to comply with clause 2.1.1. The clause updates section 74D of the Community Services Act 1970 by increasing the penalty from a minimum of $20 dollars or imprisonment to a maximum of 1 penalty unit, which is currently $104.81. Clause 2.1.3 sets out some examples of a reasonable excuse for the purpose of clause 2.1.2. The list is not exhaustive. It is longer than the current list in section 74C(iii) of the Community Services Act 1970, and has been updated to reflect the various situations that can occur. Clause 2.1.4 enables a principal or teacher to require parents to provide the reasons for a child's absence from school and to record the reasons given by the parents. Clause 2.1.5 updates and merges the current section 74G of the Community Services Act 1970 and 53(3) of the Education Act 1958 to authorise the Minister to exempt a child from attending school. The most common use of this clause is to exempt children at short notice so that they can perform at musicals or on TV. Clause 2.1.6 repeats section 79 of the Education Act 1958, which states that any parent may perform a parental duty, and that a duty performed by one parent satisfies the duty imposed on both parents. Division 2--Enforcement of Attendance Clause 2.1.7 repeats section 74B of the Community Services Act 1970 which enables the Minister to appoint school attendance officers (more commonly known as truant officers). Clause 2.1.8 is new and requires the Minister to issue an identity card to a school attendance officer. Clause 2.1.9 is new and requires a school attendance officer to produce his or her identity card before exercising their powers, or if asked to do so during the exercise of his or her powers. 16

 


 

Clause 2.1.10 updates section 74B(4) of the Community Services Act 1970 and 54(3) of the Education Act 1958 to enable a school attendance officer to question children in public places and inspect the school's attendance register kept under clause 4.3.7. Clause 2.1.11 repeats section 74B(5) of the Community Services Act 1970 to create an offence for hindering or obstructing a school attendance officer. The maximum penalty has been increased from $250 to 60 penalty units. Clause 2.1.12 repeats section 74B(3) of the Community Services Act 1970 which authorises a school attendance officer to bring proceedings for offences. Clause 2.1.13 repeats section 74E of the Community Services Act 1970 which states that a certificate signed by a principal of a registered school is to be evidence as to the attendance of a child. Clause 2.1.14 repeats section 74F(a) and (b) of the Community Services Act 1970, which states that the burden of proving the grounds of a reasonable excuse lies on the parent (as the defendant), and other evidentiary matters. PART 2.2--GOVERNMENT SCHOOLS Division 1--Establishment of Government Schools Clause 2.2.1 updates section 21 of the Education Act 1958 and sets out the Minister's power to establish Government schools, school related services and to provide for education services other than through schools. School related services cover matters such as school libraries and training of teachers. Education services not provided through schools cover matters such as education programs in children hospitals or prisons. Clause 2.2.2 repeats section 21A of the Education Act 1958 which prevents the Minister's decision to close a school from being challenged in any court or before the Ombudsman. Clause 2.2.3 repeats section 21B of the Education Act 1958 which limits the rights of persons (mainly protesters and trespassers) to claim damages for injuries occurring on discontinued Government schools. 17

 


 

Division 2--Instruction in Government Schools Clause 2.2.4 updates section 22(2) of the Education Act 1958 to provide that instruction to year 12 or its equivalent in specified learning areas is to be free to students under 20 years of age in Government schools. Section 22(2) of the Education Act 1958 limits free instruction to "pupils" but does not define "pupils". The meaning of "equivalent" will be determined by the Minister under sub clause (3), but is likely to cover certificates I and II listed in the VET sector of the Australian Qualifications Framework. Clause 2.2.5 provides that students over 20 years of age in Government schools may be charged fees in accordance with the regulations. It is similar to section 82(j) of the Education Act 1958 which enables regulations to be made prescribing scales of fees, however the new clause will also enable regulations to be made for instruction in the specified learning areas. Clause 2.2.6 repeats section 25AA of the Education Act 1958 to provide that parents of a student with a disability are not required to contribute to the cost of additional support. Clause 2.2.7 is new and sets out the position on voluntary financial contributions. Clause 2.2.8 repeats section 25A of the Education Act 1958 and requires overseas students in Government schools to pay fees in accordance with a Ministerial Order. Clause 2.2.9 repeats section 25A of the Education Act 1958 and enables the Minister to make Orders about the payment of fees by overseas students. Clause 2.2.10 updates section 23(1) of the Education Act 1958. Whilst the clause maintains the current position that education in Government schools must be secular, it clarifies that schools can discuss events or topics that involve religion and can teach VCE subjects such as texts and traditions. Education in respect of these matters is defined as "general religious education", but the clause also provides that in so doing, school cannot promote any religion. 18

 


 

Clause 2.2.11 repeats section 23(2) to (4) of the Education Act 1958 to provide that "special religious instruction" is voluntary and can only be given by accredited instructors and authorises the Minister to approve the holding of pageants and other events. "Special religious instruction" is defined to cover instruction provided by churches and other religious groups. The word "special" is new in this clause, so as to distinguish it from the "general" religious education referred to in clause 2.2.10. Clause 2.2.12 repeats section 24 of the Education Act 1958 to require students to observe a ceremony to acknowledge their role as Australian citizens. Division 3--Admission to Government Schools Clause 2.2.13 is new and provides a child of compulsory school age with the right to attend his or her designated neighbourhood Government school. Clause 2.2.14 is new and provides a child of compulsory school age may be enrolled at a Government school which is not his or her designated neighbourhood school if there is sufficient accommodation for the child at the school. Unlike clause 2.2.13, this clause does not provide an entitlement to attend a school. Instead, it provides discretion to enrol students who would otherwise not be entitled under 2.2.13. Clause 2.2.15 updates section 63(1) of the Education Act 1958 and clarifies the right to refuse enrolment to a child if the child is not otherwise entitled to be enrolled under clause 2.2.13 or some other clause. Clause 2.2.16 updates section 63(2) of the Education Act 1958 and enables the Minister to decide the criteria for determining a designated neighbourhood Government school for the purpose of clause 2.2.13, and entry criteria for a particular school. Entry criteria will cover schools such as Melbourne High School which requires an entrance examination and special schools which cater solely for students with special needs. Clause 2.2.17 is new and enables a person to be refused admission or enrolment in a Government school to ensure the safety of that student or other students. It is designed to cover situations where students have been the subject of serious assaults or abuse by other students. 19

 


 

Clause 2.2.18 repeats section 25C of the Education Act 1958 to permit principals to refuse the enrolment of a person, if that person is of or above the age stated in regulations. Division 4--Discipline of Students Clause 2.2.19 repeats section 25 of the Education Act 1958 to authorise a principal to suspend or expel a student from a Government school in accordance with any Ministerial Order. Ministerial Orders currently enable a student to be suspended or expelled by the principal if the student engages in defined behaviour either at school or travelling to or from school. Division 5--Assistance for Students with Special Needs Clause 2.2.20 updates section 32 of the Education Act 1958 which enables the Minister to supply meals to hungry children at Government schools. The new clause enables the Minister to provide a range of services to children with special needs. PART 2.3--GOVERNMENT SCHOOL COUNCILS Division 1--Definitions Clause 2.3.1 contains definitions of pre-school, school, teacher and teaching staff. The definition of school now includes a proposed school, so as to permit the creation of a council of a proposed school and for the council to operate on the first day on which a school opens with students. Division 2--Constitution of School Councils Clause 2.3.2 updates section 13 of the Education Act 1958 and authorises the Minister by Order to constitute a council of a Government school. The updates are-- · sub clause (2)(b) clarifies and confirms the current practice that an Order may provide for the election of members; · sub clause (2)(c) enables the making of Orders imposing duties on members of councils, so as to be consistent with the provisions of the Public Administration Act 2004; · sub clause 2(d) clarifies the capacity of an Order to limit the powers, duties or functions of councils; 20

 


 

· sub clause (4) has the effect that an Order comes into operation on the day it is made or any later date stated in the Order; · sub clause (9) only requires a notice to be published of the making of the more important Orders; · sub clause (15) permits members of councils to be reimbursed reasonable expenses incurred by the member. Clause 2.3.3 repeats section 15G of the Education Act 1958 to permit the Minister to exercise the powers of a council in respect of a school if no school council exists. Division 3--Objectives, Functions and Powers of School Councils Clause 2.3.4 is new and sets out the objectives of a school council. Paragraph (a) is taken from section 13(1) of the Education Act 1958 which refers to constituting a council to assist in the efficient conduct of a school. Paragraph (b) reflects article 3.1 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child which Australia ratified in December 1990. The convention makes the best interests of the child at least a "primary consideration" and sometimes a "paramount" consideration in actions and decisions affecting children. Paragraph (b) does not express the objective as the paramount or the only consideration, as sometimes financial constraints and other criteria will be determinative. For example, student suspensions or expulsions prohibit the objective being a paramount consideration. Paragraph (c) which refers to enhancing the educational opportunities of students of the school and reflects the purpose of the school plan referred to in clause 2.3.24, which is to set out the school's goals and targets over the next 4 years. Clause 2.3.5 updates the functions of councils of Government schools. The purpose of this clause is to group together, as far as practicable, all the functions of councils and to distinguish between functions and powers. 21

 


 

Clause 2.3.6 sets out the powers of a school council for the purpose of meeting its objectives or performing its functions or duties. It is important to note that the powers can only be used for one of the stated objectives, functions or duties. Sub clause 1(c) is new. It refers to councils charging fees. It is subject to clause 2.2.4 which covers free instruction to students and any Ministerial Order. The fees may cover matters such as the costs of excursions or extra curriculum programs or facilities provided to students. Sub clause (1)(d) is new. It provides a council with power to do all things as are necessary or convenient to be done for, or in connection with, meeting its objectives or performing its functions or duties. This introduces for the first time a general power for a council to undertake its objectives, functions and duties. Sub clause (3) then limits this general power to ensure it is not used too widely or for unintended areas. Sub clause (3)(a) and (b) states a council does not have power to employ full time teaching staff or purchase or acquire for consideration any land or building. Clause 2.3.7 Sub clause (1) states a council is accountable to the Minister and repeats section 15O of the Education Act 1958. Sub clause (2) sets out the duties of the principal as the executive officer of the council and repeats regulation 33 of the Education Regulations 2000. It has been inserted in the Bill to emphasise its importance. Division 4--Employment of Staff Clause 2.3.8 updates section 15B of the Education Act 1958 and empowers councils to employ teaching and other staff in schools. The employment of teaching staff is subject to clause 2.3.6(3)(a) which prevents councils employing permanent teaching staff. Clause 2.3.9 Sub clause (1) repeats section 15B(4) of the Education Act 1958, which makes any person convicted or found guilty of a sexual offence against a child ineligible to be employed as a teacher by a council. 22

 


 

Sub clause (2) repeats section 15B(5) of the Education Act 1958, which requires a person to be registered by the VIT to be eligible for employment by a council as a teacher. This employment basically covers persons delivering an education program, but not teacher aides, teacher assistants or student teachers. Clause 2.3.10 repeats sections 15B(6) to (11) of the Education Act 1958 which provide that a council must dismiss a teacher convicted of a sexual offence against a child and contains other provisions dealing with a teacher's registration being suspended or cancelled. Division 5--Further Powers of School Councils Clause 2.3.11 empowers councils of Government schools to permit the use of school buildings and grounds by the community. Clause 2.3.12 empowers councils of Government schools to carry out works at the school. Clause 2.3.13 empowers public bodies to enter agreements with councils of Government schools to perform works at the school. Clause 2.3.14 authorises councils of Government schools to form sub- committees. Clause 2.3.15 authorises a council of a Government school to delegate its powers, duties or functions to any person or body. It widens section 15B(1)(f) of the Education Act 1958. Clause 2.3.16 authorises a council of a Government school to form committees to manage joint facilities. These joint facilities are buildings or grounds which have been developed on school premises by the contribution of a number of parties. Clause 2.3.17 authorises a council of a Government school that forms a committee under clause 2.3.16 to delegate, with the approval of the Minister, powers, duties or functions to members of the committee. Clause 2.3.18 authorises a council of a Government school to sell property. Division 6--Pre school Programs This Division empowers councils of Government schools to operate pre school programs. 23

 


 

Division 7--Reporting and Accountability Requirements Clause 2.3.24 requires councils of Government schools to prepare a school plan. The clause replaces section 15K of the Education Act 1958 which requires councils to prepare a school charter. This clause is linked to clause 2.3.4(c), which refers to an objective of councils as being to enhancing the educational opportunities of students of the school. This objective is linked to the school plan which will set out the school's goals and targets over the next 4 years. Clause 2.3.25 states the status of school plan as not giving rise to legal relations. Clause 2.3.26 sets out how the Secretary may terminate a school plan. Clause 2.3.27 requires councils of Government schools to prepare an annual report. It updates and merges section 14(2), 15F(2), 15P and 15Q(4) of the Education Act 1958. The updates involve the council including the school plan in its annual report; the council having to make the annual report available to any person upon request; and the preparation of financial statements in a form to facilitate councils moving to accrual accounting. Clause 2.3.28 authorises the Auditor-General to audit the accounts of councils of Government schools. Clause 2.3.29 requires councils of Government schools to use funds for any school purpose, unless the funding is provided for a specific purpose. Clause 2.3.30 will require the Minister to ensure that the Department's report of operations under section 45 of the Financial Management Act 1994 include a summary of the information provided by councils in their annual reports under clause 2.3.27, and any other information required by the Minister administering that Act. Councils will also have to comply with a new school accountability and reporting framework and regulations requiring councils to keep accounts and records in a form determined by the Secretary. 24

 


 

This change will not affect the Auditor General's power to audit councils of Government schools. This is retained by clause 2.3.28, and also because school councils are still public bodies under the Audit Act 1994, by virtue of the definition of that term in section 3 of that Act. Division 8--General Clause 2.3.31 limits the ability of councils of Government schools to commence legal proceedings (including the prerogative writs and declarations and injunctions) against Government bodies without the approval of the Minister. It updates section 14B of the Education Act 1958 which prevents councils from commencing legal proceeding against any person without the Minister's approval. Section 14B is considered to be too wide in respect of the persons it prohibits proceedings against, and the clause will no longer require the Minister's approval to commence proceedings against non-Government bodies. Clause 2.3.32 provides an indemnity to the members of a council of a Government school. It repeats section 14C of the Education Act 1958. PART 2.4--GOVERNMENT TEACHING SERVICE This Part inserts the current Teaching Service Act 1981 which deals with the conditions of employment in the teaching service, the Minister's powers to make Orders about the teaching service, the Secretary's employment powers in respect of the teaching service, and the establishment and functions of the Merit Protection Boards and Discipline Appeals Boards. The main changes to the current Teaching Service Act 1981 provisions are-- · The terminology in certified agreements and awards has been used. As a consequence, the term "officer" is changed to "ongoing employee". Employee is changed to "temporary employee". All persons in the teaching service are referred to as "employees" in place of the current terms of officer and employee. Using the term "employee" also mirrors the terminology used in the Public Administration Act 2004. · Clause 2.4.3 provides that the Secretary, on behalf of the Crown, employs all persons in the teaching service. This updates section 3 of the Teaching Service Act 1981 which states all persons are employed by "Her Majesty", and section 18 which states that the Secretary is the employer of principals. The change also reflects the provisions of section 3A of the Teaching Service Act 1981 25

 


 

and section 20 of the Public Administration Act 2004 which vests in the Secretary, on behalf of the Crown, all the rights and powers of an employer in respect of employees in the Department employed under those Acts. · Clause 2.4.3 (3) provides examples of the Secretary's powers as an employer. It is similar to section 20 of the Public Administration Act 2000 and elaborates on section 3A of the Teaching Service Act 1981. · Employees (mainly School Services Officers) currently employed by the Secretary under section 5 of the Education Act 1958 are to be employed by the Secretary under the Government teaching service (ref. clause 2.4.3). They continue to be excluded from requiring VIT registration as they do not fall under the definition of teacher. This will reduce the modes of employment in the Department from 4 to 3 (being the teaching service, school council employment and the Public Administration Act 2004. · Clause 2.4.82 inserts immunities against legal action for members of the Merit Protection Boards and Discipline Appeals Board. The immunities are consistent with Government policy. Whilst protecting the members against legal action, the clause entitles persons to take legal action against the Crown instead of the members. · Changes have been made to reflect the contents of certified agreements and awards. This involves-- · enabling appointment and appeal criteria for appointments to be determined by Ministerial Order, so as to reflect the "merit" criteria used in certified agreements and any subsequent changes to the agreements; · inserting clause 2.4.25 to authorise the making of Orders which entitle persons to long service leave for less than 10 years service; · amending clause 2.4.8 to provide that the period of probation is to be determined by Ministerial Order, rather than specifying a 12 month period; · acknowledging in clause 2.4.2 that the teaching service provisions are subject to certified agreements and awards. 26

 


 

PART 2.5--VICTORIAN CURRICULUM AND ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY Clauses 2.5.1 to 2.5.24 insert the current Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority Act 2000 which deals with the establishment, membership, functions and powers of the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority. The main changes to the current Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority Act 2000 provisions are-- · The VCAA's capacity to exercise its powers outside Victoria is clarified (ref. clause 2.5.5 (1)(f)). This will confirm its capacity to conduct assessments of students in years 11 and 12 in courses conducted overseas. For overseas locations, the VCAA enters into a contract with the overseas provider, under which the provider must meet the VCAA standards for facilities, staff and other resources. Sometimes a Victorian based school conducts a campus overseas, and an agreement with the Victorian based school provides the means to the VCAA maintaining appropriate standards overseas. · New powers are inserted to enable the VCAA to make special provision for students who suffer from illness, trauma, disability, misadventure or examination irregularities (ref. clause 2.5.11). · The VCAA is given powers to issue qualifications in respect of accredited courses which the VCAA owns such as the VCE and VCAL (ref. clause 2.5.3 (3) and (4). The VRQA will still have the function of deciding whether to accredit a course and approve providers, but the ownership and control of the VCE and VCAL will reside with the VCAA as the owner. This new function is also mirrored in clause 2.5.3(1)(b) which refers to the VCAA performing the functions of a body registered under Chapter 4. · Clause 2.5.8 applies the provisions of Schedule 2 to the VCAA. That schedule contains common clauses for statutory bodies such as the VCAA. 27

 


 

PART 2.6--VICTORIAN INSTITUTE OF TEACHING Clauses 2.6.1 to 2.6.78 insert the current Victorian Institute of Teaching Act 2001, which requires all teachers in Victorian schools to be registered with the VIT, and deals with the establishment, membership, functions and powers of the Victorian Institute of Teaching. The main changes to the current Victorian Institute of Teaching Act 2001 provisions are-- · New categories of non practising registration and also interim registration have been introduced (ref. clause 2.6.11 and 2.6.12). Most of the non practising members are on family leave and would not be able to renew their current registration because they cannot satisfy the requirement of maintaining an appropriate level of professional practice. The category of interim registration has been introduced because the VIT Council meets at approximately 5 week intervals, and many persons are recommended for registration in between Council meetings and schools are anxious to employ these people immediately. · Discretion is given to the VIT to determine the date by which annual registration fees must be paid (ref. clause 2.6.21). The current Act provides for all teachers to pay the fee on the one date, which is difficult to administer. · The VIT is given-- · disciplinary powers over teachers found to be seriously incompetent (ref. clause 2.6.9(1)(e) and 2.6.30), or if deregistered in other jurisdictions (ref. clause 2.6.9(1)(d) and 2.6.30); · powers to impose conditions on a teacher's registration (ref. clause 2.6.9(3)); · powers to suspend the registration of a teacher charged with a sexual offence (ref. clause 2.6.27), after giving notice to the teacher and the opportunity for the teacher to make submissions; · Clause 2.6.61 applies the provisions of Schedule 2 to the VIT. That schedule contains common clauses for statutory bodies such as the VIT. 28

 


 

· Clause 2.6.76 updates the current section 80 of the Act by inserting an immunity for members of a VIT and hearing panels who hear discipline matters. The immunity is consistent with Government policy. Whilst protecting the members against legal action, the clause entitles persons to take legal action against the Crown instead of the members; · Section 94 of the current Act, which requires the first College of the VIT to be established by the Minister, has been replaced by clause 2.6.78 which requires the establishment of any College for principals to have the approval of the Minister; CHAPTER 3--POST SCHOOL EDUCATION AND TRAINING PART 3.1--VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING Clauses 3.1.1 to 3.1.34 insert the provisions of the current Vocational Education and Training Act 1990 ("the VET Act"), which deals with the establishment, functions and powers of-- · the Victorian Skills Commission (being the current Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission); · Technical and Further Education institutes; · Industry Training Boards. The main changes to the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission are-- · The name of the Commission is changed to the "Victorian Skills Commission" ("VSC") under clause 3.1.1. · The maximum membership of the Commission has been increased by 2 members under clause 3.1.7(1)(e). The 2 persons are to have direct industry experience and/or experience in the training system, so as broaden the skill base of the VSC, and provide additional resources for its workload. · The statement of the functions of the Commission at clause 3.1.2 has been simplified and updated to reflect current functions. 29

 


 

· The repeal of the Australian National Training Authority Act of the Commonwealth and the passing of the Skilling Australia's Workforce Act 2005 necessitated various amendments to the Vocational Education and Training and Victorian Qualifications Authority provisions. · Clauses 3.1.2 (1)(f) and 3.1.3 set out the Commission's role under the Skilling Australia's Workforce Act 2005. Clause 3.1.3, in authorising the Minister to nominate the Commission as the State Training Authority for Victoria under the Skilling Australia's Workforce Act 2005, has been worded as it is, so as to satisfy the requirements of that Act, which define a State Training Authority as meaning "in relation to a State, a person, organisation or body nominated as the State Training Authority for that State by the Minister of the State who has responsibility for vocational education and training". · Clause 3.1.8 applies the provisions of Schedule 2 to the VSC. That schedule contains common clauses for statutory bodies such as the VSC. · The Bill updates the immunities in the current provisions in line with Government policy, by removing the current immunity in section 22 of the Act for the members of the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission. · The provisions on Approved Training Agents, which are referred to in section 20B of the Vocational Education and Training Act 1990, have been grouped with other relevant provisions and are in clauses 5.5.20 to 5.5.22 of the Bill. The Minister will in future establish those bodies instead of the Governor in Council. The main changes to the Technical and Further Education provisions are-- · All references to TAFE colleges have been changed to TAFE institutes. · All references to TAFE councils have been changed to TAFE boards. 30

 


 

· All references to members of TAFE councils have been changed to directors of TAFE Boards. · Section 28(1)(a) of the VET Act 1990, which requires that an Order establishing the TAFE council must provide for not less than one half of its members to be appointed by the Minister, has been amended to provide that the Order establishing the Board must provide for at least a majority of its directors to be appointed by the Minister. This will mirror changes made to the Public Administration Act 2004. · TAFE council members do not currently receive remuneration (other than reimbursement of expenses) for their role on a council. Item 3 of Schedule 2 will enable the Governor in Council to prescribe remuneration for members. · Clause 3.1.12(2) authorises the Minister to make some Orders with respect to the constitution of TAFE boards. · Clause 3.1.17 applies the provisions of Schedule 2 to a board of a TAFE institute. That schedule contains common clauses for statutory bodies such as boards of TAFE Institutes. · The Bill updates the immunities in the current provisions in line with Government policy, by removing the current immunity in section 36 of the VET Act for members of boards of TAFE institutes. The main changes relating to Industry Training Boards are as follows-- · Industry Training Boards will in future be established by the Minister. They are currently established by the Governor in Council. The same change has been made for establishing Approved Training Agents and bodies to advise the Minister on post secondary education. · The Bill updates the immunities in the current provisions in line with Government policy, by removing the immunity in section 45 of the VET Act for members of Industry Training Boards. 31

 


 

PART 3.2--HIGHER EDUCATION Clauses 3.2.1 to 3.2.12 insert only the following provisions of the current Tertiary Education Act 1993-- · in Division 1, the voluntary student provisions of section 12A to 12I of the Tertiary Education Act 1993; · in Division 2, the establishment of post secondary education institutions by the Governor in Council. The following provisions of the current Tertiary Education Act 1993 are being transferred to the administration of the new Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority established under Chapter 4-- · endorsing courses of study under the current section 6 as being suitable for overseas students; · approving institutions under the current section 10 (other than universities established or recognised under an Act) to operate as a Universities; · authorising institutions under the current section 11 (other than universities established or recognised under an Act or approved under section 10) to offer higher education courses or awards; and accrediting higher education courses; · reviewing under the current section 11A the operations of these matters; · the appointment and powers of authorised officers under the current sections 11B to 11D; · the keeping of a register of higher education courses and institutions under the current section 12. The following sections of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 have been merged with other clauses in other Parts of the Bill-- · the power in the current section 4 to establish bodies to advise the Minister; · the power in the current section 5 to require information; · the Minister's delegation power in the current section 21; and · the power in the current section 8 to acquire lands for education purposes. 32

 


 

PART 3.3--ADULT, COMMUNITY AND FURTHER EDUCATION Clauses 3.3.1 to 3.3.43 insert the provisions of the Adult Community and Further Education Act 1991 ("the ACFE Act"), which deals with the establishment, functions and powers of-- · the Adult Community and Further Education Board; · Regional Councils of Adult Community and Further Education; · Adult Education Institutions, and specifically the Adult Multicultural Education Services and the Centre for Adult Education. The main changes to the Adult Community and Further Education provisions are as follows-- · The membership provisions for the ACFE Board at clause 3.3.10 have been amended so as remove the need to appoint members who meet defined criteria. The current descriptions of the categories at section 19(1) of the Adult Community and Further Education Act 1991 makes the selection of Board members often difficult or with forced alignments, and the categories themselves are dated. · The Bill leaves in place section 19(2) which requires the Minister to have regard to ensuring the overall membership meets certain criteria. · Clause 3.3.21 reduces the current 12 person membership of ACFE regional councils to 9 persons. · Clause 3.3.22 amends the current detailed membership criteria in section 38(3) of the ACFE Act to provide that the Minister is to have regard to ensuring the overall membership meets certain criteria. · Clause 3.3.29(1)(e) amends the current section 47(1)(e) of the ACFE Act to provide that the Governor in Council Order establishing an Adult Education Institution may provide that the members of its governing board may receive remuneration. · The immunity for ACFE Board members in section 32 of the ACFE Act has been deleted. 33

 


 

· The immunity for members of ACFE regional councils in section 42 of the ACFE Act has been deleted. · Clauses 3.3.11 and 3.3.39 apply Schedule 2 to the ACFE Board and Adult Education Institutions. That schedule contains common clauses for statutory bodies. CHAPTER 4--VICTORIAN REGISTRATION AND QUALIFICATIONS AUTHORITY This Chapter-- · establishes the new Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority; · requires the following to be registered-- · home schooling; · schools; · providers of accredited-- · senior secondary courses; · Vocational Education and Training courses; · providers of higher education courses; · providers of courses to overseas students; · creates offences in Part 4.7 for doing things without being registered (or approved as the case requires) by the VRQA under this Chapter-- · providing and accredited course without being authorised to provide the course; · awarding a qualification on the State Register without being authorised to award the qualification; · operating or purporting to operate as a University (this does not apply to Universities established or recognised under an Act); · conferring, or offering to confer a higher education award, or offering a course of study in higher education (this does not apply to Universities established or recognised under an Act, the Melbourne College of Divinity or an autonomous college established under 3.2.11). 34

 


 

The Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 of the Commonwealth creates offences of providing courses to overseas students without being endorsed by the relevant State authority. The VRQA will assume the functions currently performed by the Registered Schools Board and Victorian Qualifications Authority. The Registered Schools Board currently registers non-Government schools under 34 IA of the Education Act 1958. The VQA currently deals with courses, providers and qualifications after year 10 excluding higher education, and accredits courses, recognises qualifications, and registers persons who are authorised to provide a course or award the qualification. The new matters that the VRQA will handle are-- · the registration of home schooling; · the registration of all schools; · higher education course and provider approvals (this does not include Universities established under an Act); and · approving providers of courses to overseas students. PART 4.1--PRELIMINARY Clause 4.1.1 contains definitions. The definitions are those in the current Victorian Qualifications Authority Act 2000 (VQA Act) and the Tertiary Education Act 1993. The definition of Ministerial council has been amended in view of its new meaning in the Commonwealth Skilling Australia's Workforce Act 2005. The definition is relevant to the definitions of the AQTF and RTO standards. The definition of AQF at clause 1.1.3 refers to a different Ministerial council. In particular it also includes the Ministers for Youth Affairs. PART 4.2--VICTORIAN REGISTRATION AND QUALIFICATIONS AUTHORITY Clause 4.2.1 establishes the VRQA as a new authority. The Public Administration Act 2004 will apply to its governance principles and also places duties on the directors of the Authority, and Division 3 deals with the removal or suspension of directors. 35

 


 

Clause 4.2.2 sets out the functions of the VRQA. It will be responsible for-- · the registration of all schools (both Government and non-Government) and home schooling; · in relation to years 11 and 12 of schooling, and vocational education and training or further education-- · accrediting courses; · authorising providers of accredited courses; · registering qualifications; · authorising providers to award registered qualifications; · in relation to higher education-- · accrediting courses; and · approving and authorising providers of higher education; and · approving all providers of courses to overseas students. Other functions cover the State Register, conducting audits, and ensuring the public availability of information about education providers. Clause 4.2.3 sets out the powers of the VRQA and clarifies its ability to exercise its powers outside Victoria. This is necessary to enable the VRQA to approve providers of accredited courses where the provider is situated overseas. Also some Victorian schools have a campus overseas. Clause 4.2.4 sets out the membership of the Authority. It will have a smaller membership (being reduced from between 10 and 15, to 9 and 12 members), and the detailed membership categories being replaced with the requirement that the Minister must be satisfied with the overall membership criteria. Clause 4.2.5 applies the common clauses for statutory bodies in Schedule 2 to the VRQA. The Schedule is subject to the express provisions of the Bill and also Part 5 of the Public Administration Act 2004. 36

 


 

Clause 4.2.6 sets out the Director's responsibilities. Clause 4.2.7 contains the delegation power of the Authority. Clause 4.2.8 repeats the existing requirement for the VRQA to maintain a Fund in its name of all moneys received by it. PART 4.3--REGISTRATION OF STUDENTS AND PROVIDERS Division 1--Schools Clause 4.3.1 authorises the VRQA to register schools and sets out the minimum criteria that schools must satisfy in order to be registered. This clause is linked to clause 4.7.1 which creates the offence of carrying on a school unless registered. It sets out the minimum criteria for registering schools. The clause also refers to prescribed minimum standards, which means that regulations will be made establishing those standards. Clause 4.3.2 is new and deals with the review of the operation of schools after they have been registered. It sets out the different ways by which the VRQA can satisfy itself that a school continues to comply with the standards for registration. Clause 4.3.3 contains the VRQA's power to review the operation of a school to determine whether it continues to comply with the standards for registration under the Bill. It also sets out the procedure the VRQA must follow if it intends to take any action under clause 4.3.4 against the school for failing to comply with the standards. The action under clause 4.3.4 can include suspending or cancelling the school's registration, imposing conditions on its registration, or prohibiting it from enrolling new students. The VRQA must also give the Minister notice of the proposed action and must comply with any directions of the Minister. The Minister's power to direct the VRQA is expected to be used in special or exceptional circumstances, for example, where the proposed conditions are considered unreasonable, or a suspension of registration might cause unreasonable hardship to students or parents, or where the public interest justifies the school being given greater time to comply with the new requirements. Clause 4.3.4 sets out the action that the VRQA may take against a school that fails to comply with the standards for registration. 37

 


 

Clause 4.3.5 requires registered schools to provide the VRQA with a report required by the regulations. Clause 4.3.6 requires a notice of the school's registration to be displayed at or near the main entrance. Clause 4.3.7 requires schools to maintain an attendance register of students of compulsory school age (ie 6 to 16) in accordance with the regulations. Clause 4.3.8 requires the VRQA to keep a register of schools registered by it. Division 2--Registration of students for home schooling Clause 4.3.9 is new and authorises the VRQA to register students for home schooling in accordance with the regulations and sets out the grounds on which the registration may be cancelled. An authorised officer does not have the right under clause 5.8.3(3) to enter residential premises where registered home schooling takes place. Division 3--Vocational Education and Training Clause 4.3.10 deals with the registration of education and training organisations to conduct accredited vocational education and training courses or to award registered qualifications. Clause 4.3.11 is similar to section 23(4) to (5) of the VQA Act. It sets out some minimum standards, and otherwise provides that regulations are to set out the minimum standards for registration for Vocational Education and Training. Clause 4.3.12 sets out the terms of registration to conduct accredited vocational education and training courses. Division 4--National Registration The clauses in this division deal with the National Registration scheme, which in summary is an Australia wide scheme under which bodies registered by one State for vocational education and training or further education are recognised in all other States to conduct accredited courses, and to award registered qualifications. If on the National Register, the body is known as an RTO, ie a Registered Training Organisation. This is also the defined meaning of the term RTO in clause 4.1.1. 38

 


 

Division 5--Higher Education Clause 4.3.30 authorises the VRQA to approve institutions to operate as Universities. It repeats section 10(1A) to (6) and (10) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 with the following changes-- · The current section authorises the Minister to approve institutions, whereas the clause authorises the VRQA to do so. This is part of the transfer of a number of functions to the VRQA to provide the public, as far as practicable, with a "one stop shop" for education approvals. · The criteria for registration in sub clause (4) has been updated from the current section 10(3), so as to focus more on the National Protocols for Higher Education Approvals. This not only shortens and simplifies the section, but also provides for any changes to the National Protocols to be automatically captured by the clause. · The prohibition in the section 10(1) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993, which prohibits institutions operating as a University unless approved, has been moved to clause 4.7.5, which groups all the offences in one Part. The prohibition does not apply to Universities established or recognised under an Act. Such Universities do not need further approval under clause 4.3.30 to operate as a University. Clause 4.3.31 authorises the VRQA to suspend or revoke an institution's approval to operate as a University. It repeats section 10(7)(8) and (11) to (14) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 with the change that the VRQA, rather than the Minister, exercises the powers. Clause 4.3.32 provides for disallowance by Parliament of notices relating to approvals to operate as a University. 39

 


 

Clause 4.3.33 authorises the VRQA to approve institutions to offer courses of study in higher education. It updates section 11(2) to (7) and (12) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 with the following changes-- · As in clause 4.3.30, the criteria for registration in sub clause (2) has been updated so as to focus more on the National Protocols for Higher Education Approvals; · The current section 11 (1)(e) and (3) and (4) refer to the Minister "accrediting" a course of study and also "approving" an institution to conduct a course of study. Clause 4.3.33 refers to the VRQA "authorising" an institution to conduct a course of study. For the purpose of merging similar powers, the accrediting function has been moved to clause 4.4.2(3) which refers to the VRQA accrediting courses in higher education; · The VRQA, rather than the Minister, exercises the powers. The prohibition in section 11(1) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993, which prohibits institutions conferring or offering to confer a higher education award, or offering courses of study in higher education, has been moved to clause 4.7.7, which groups all the offences in one Part. The prohibition does not apply to Universities established or recognised under an Act. Such Universities do not need further approval under clause 4.3.33. Clause 4.3.34 authorises the VRQA to suspend or revoke an institution's authorisation to conduct an accredited course of study in higher education. It repeats section 11(8) to (9) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993, with the change that the VRQA, rather than the Minister, exercises the powers. Courses in higher education are accredited under clause 4.4.2(3), and the VRQA's function statement at clause 4.2.2(1)(f) refers to it accrediting those courses. 40

 


 

Clause 4.3.35 authorises the VRQA to review operations of universities approved under clause 4.3.30 to operate in Victoria, or to review operations of an institution approved under clause 4.3.32 to offer a course of study. This clause does not apply to a University established under a Victorian Act of Parliament. The clause repeats section 11A of the Tertiary Education Act 1993, with the change that the VRQA, rather than the Minister, exercises the powers. Division 6--Approval to exercise delegated powers Clause 4.3.36 is linked to clause 4.2.7, both of which deal with the VRQA's ability to delegate its powers. It updates section 23A of the VQA Act 2000 which enables the Authority to investigate organisations to determine whether the organisation should be delegated the Authority's powers under clause 4.2.7(3). The current section has been updated in sub clause (1)(a) and (b) by adding a reference to Universities and other institutions authorised to conduct higher education courses. PART 4.4--ACCREDITATION AND QUALIFICATIONS Division 1--Investigation and Accreditation Clause 4.4.1 repeats section 21 of the VQA Act and authorises the VRQA to investigate a course to determine whether it should be accredited. Clause 4.4.2 merges and updates section 22 of the VQA Act and section 11(3) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 so as to set out the criteria the VRQA is to have regard to when considering whether to accredit courses in-- · VET and further education--under sub clause (2); · Higher education--under sub clause (3); · other matters--under sub clause (1). Sub clause (1)(d) adds a new criteria so as to take into account whether any relevant fee has been paid. Clause 4.4.3 merges and updates section 22A of the VQA Act and section 11(8) and 11A(5) to (7) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993. It sets out the powers of the VRQA to cancel or suspend an accreditation of a course and the procedures it must follow if doing so. 41

 


 

Clause 4.4.4 enables the VRQA to review an accredited higher education course for the purpose of determining whether the course continues to attain the appropriate standards. It is a shorter version of section 11A(3)(i) of the VQA Act. Division 2--Qualifications Clause 4.4.5 repeats section 24(2) of the VQA Act and enables bodies registered under clause 4.3.10 to award qualifications. It is also updated by a new sub clause (2) which enables the VRQA to provide the qualification or statement of completion of the course if the registered body ceases to exist. PART 4.5--OVERSEAS STUDENTS This Part 4.5 merges the current powers of-- · the Minister under section 65 of the Education Act 1958 to endorse courses in non-Government schools as suitable for overseas students; · the Minister under section 6 of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 to endorse higher education courses as suitable for overseas students; · the VQA under section 27 of the VQA Act to approve other courses as suitable for overseas students. The provision of services to overseas students is governed by the Commonwealth's Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 (the ESOS Act). That Act requires providers to be approved by the relevant State authority and imposes penalties for persons or bodies that provide services without that approval. It also sets out the requirements that providers must comply with, including a National Code of Practice issued under Part 4 of that Act. Clause 4.5.1 authorises the VRQA to approve a registered school (which will cover both Government and non-Government schools), a University or other education and training organisation to offer a course to overseas students. The clause updates the current long and different lists of criteria in section 6(3) of the Tertiary Education Act 1993, 65(3) of the Education Act 1958 and 27(3) of the VQA Act by replacing them with a reference to the National Code of Practice issued under Part 4 of the ESOS Act. 42

 


 

The Department currently approves Government schools whereas under this clause the VRQA will have the function. Clause 4.5.1 (5) amends the current section 27(5) of the VQA Act to enable the VRQA to approve a provider of courses to overseas students for up to 5 years, rather than a fixed 5 year period. This change mirrors the ESOS Act and other provisions of the current VQA Act. Clause 4.5.2 enables persons to apply for approval for a school, University or other institution to provide a course to overseas students. Clause 4.5.3 authorises the VRQA to suspend or cancel any approval to provide a course to overseas students. Clause 4.5.4 authorises the VRQA to review operations of approved providers of courses to overseas students. PART 4.6--STATE REGISTER This Part 4.6 groups together, merges and updates the current requirements to keep registers of registered schools, accredited courses, recognised qualifications or approved providers and higher education providers. The VRQA will be responsible for keeping the one register and clause 4.9.1 requires that the register is published on a web site maintained by the VRQA. Clause 4.6.1 requires the VRQA to maintain a State Register of all matters required to be registered under Chapter 4. Sub clause (3) which requires the Authority to register qualifications requested by the Minister and is designed to cover the registration of qualifications for apprenticeships following a recommendation to the Minister by the Victorian Skills Commission. Clause 4.6.2 requires a division in the Register to be kept of education and training organisations. Clause 4.6.3 requires a division in the Register to be kept of higher education matters. Clause 4.6.4 requires the VRQA to register on the National Register persons or bodies registered for VET and further education. 43

 


 

PART 4.7--OFFENCES This part groups together all the offence provisions in the Bill for ease of reference. The penalties for offences are expressed as penalty units. The amount of a penalty unit is fixed once each financial year by the Treasurer under section 5 of the Monetary Units Act 2004, by notice published in the Government Gazette. The amount fixed for the financial year commencing 1 July 2005 is $104.81. The clauses cover offences of-- · conducting an unregistered school; · using the titles "registered provider" or "government accredited" or "government recognised" without being registered or accredited; · falsely claiming to be a Registered Training Organisation; · issuing qualifications or claiming to be able to do so as an RTO or using terms which imply it; · claiming to be able to offer training as an RTO or using terms which imply it; · providing and accredited course without being authorised to provide the course; · awarding a qualification on the State Register without being authorised to award the qualification; · offering to provide an accredited course which is not accredited. · misleading information relating to registration on the State Register. PART 4.8--REVIEW BY VCAT Clause 4.8.1 enables a person to apply to VCAT for a review of a decision by the VRQA not to grant or approve, or to suspend or cancel a registration or approval or authorisation. In addition, the clause also gives a right of review to the following-- · Decisions concerning the registration of all schools, including Government schools. Currently Government schools do not have to be registered. This is also a change to the current position under section 42(1D) and 43(2) and (3) of the Education 44

 


 

Act 1958, which enables non-Government schools to appeal to the Minister. · Decisions concerning Government schools providing courses to overseas students. Currently, these are approved by the Department. · Decisions on home schooling. PART 4.9--INFORMATION AND EVIDENCE Clause 4.9.1 is new and requires the VRQA to publish on the Internet the State Register referred to in clause 4.6.1. Clause 4.9.2 provides that a certificate signed by members of the VRQA as to the contents of the State Register is proof of those contents, in the absence of evidence to the contrary. Clause 4.9.3 provides that a person must not give any false or misleading information relating to registration on the State Register and a penalty of 10 penalty units. Clause 4.9.4 is based on section 33A of the VQA Act and enables the VRQA to disclose information to Commonwealth bodies, such as the Department of Education, Science and Training and the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs. This is necessary to enable the VRQA to manage risks associated with courses to overseas students or that involve traineeships or apprenticeships and making arrangements for overseas students following the cessation of services by any provider. CHAPTER 5--GENERAL PART 5.1--ADMINISTRATION Clause 5.1.1 states there is to be a Department responsible for the administration of education and training in Victoria with the principal function of assisting the Minister in the administration of the Act. It also states who and what the Department consists of. Clause 5.1.2 requires the governing body of all education or training institutions and non-government schools or institutions to supply the Minister with any information she may reasonably require for the effective monitoring, development and planning of post secondary education. 45

 


 

PART 5.2--MINISTER'S POWERS Clause 5.2.3 is new but reflects the common law and also sections in current Acts. It provides the Minister with a general power in sub clause (1), followed by specific matters in sub clause (2). Sub clause (1) reflects the Minister' powers at common law to enter contracts on behalf of the government in connection with any subject matter which properly comes within her portfolio. The same power enables the Minister, in connection with the portfolio-- · to establish trusts and companies; · to be part of Australia wide Ministerial councils on matters relating to the portfolio; · to enter memoranda of understanding with other States or parties. Sub clause (2)(a) and (b) reflect the Minister's powers under current Acts. Sub clause (2)(c) to (e) reflects the Ministers powers under the Bill. Sub clause (4) repeats limits in current Acts, such as the awarding of a qualification, which is excluded from the power to issue a direction. Clause 5.2.4 is new and provides the Minister with a power to enter arrangements for multi-sector arrangements. The following matters are relevant to this clause. · The Department is moving towards multi sector modes of delivering education where a TAFE institute and a secondary school could jointly share or offer services. · Precincts are being established which establish a school, a TAFE institution and a University on one location. · New governance models are needed to administer and establish these multi sector institutes. Clause 5.2.5 enables the Minister to purchase or compulsorily acquire lands for the purpose of the Bill. It merges and updates sections 16(1), 17, 19A, 19B and 20 of the Education Act 1958 and section 8 of the Tertiary Education Act 1993. 46

 


 

Clause 5.2.6 enables the Minister to lease or grant a lease of lands. It merges and updates sections 16(1) and 18A of the Education Act 1958. Sub-clause (2) refers to leases providing a direct or indirect benefit to education, and is designed to deal more generally with the type of lease under the Baxter Technical School Land Act 1982. That Act is being repealed as obsolete, but it authorised the Minister to lease part of the school's land to the Commonwealth for defence purposes after the Commonwealth transferred the land to the State. Clause 5.2.7 provides the Minister with powers over reserved Crown lands. This clause is needed as section 8 of the Crown Lands Reserves Act 1978 prohibits the sale, lease or licence of reserved Crown lands unless authorised by that Act or expressly by another Act. Approximately one third of Education land is reserved Crown lands. Clause 5.2.8 vests all real property (ie interests in land) acquired for the Bill in the Minister and his or her successors. It also empowers the Minister to sell such property and requires the proceeds to be placed into the Consolidated Fund. It updates section 16 of the Education Act 1958. Clause 5.2.9 authorises the Minister to enter agreements and arrangements concerning the use of property. It repeats section 20A of the Education Act 1958. Clause 5.2.10 updates the Minister's powers in respect of the provision of education services outside Victoria. The current section 26A of the Education Act 1958 only provides that the Minister can enter agreements to provide the services of a State school outside Victoria. The provision of education in the international arena is a significant and growing export area, and also enhances the image of Victoria's education institutions internationally. The new clauses will enable Victoria to provide a wider range of education services overseas and to employ persons under the laws of another country, and to purchase lands overseas. Clause 5.2.11 sets out the Minister's powers of delegation. The Minister's current delegation powers are in section 8 of the Education Act, section 76 of the Teaching Service Act 1981, section 20(3)(7) and 20A of the VET Act, section 28 of the ACFE Act, section 21 of the Tertiary Education Act 1993 and section 16 of the VCAA Act. 47

 


 

The current sections are inconsistent. The clause is designed to-- · achieve a consistent approach across the portfolio, including a power to delegate matters under the VQA and VIT provisions which currently have no such powers to delegate; and · not permit the delegation of matters which are of sufficient importance that they should require the Minister's personal attention. Clause 5.2.12 enables the Governor in Council to establish bodies to advise the Minister on any matter relating to education and training. Clause 5.2.13 authorises the Minister to require a person to enter an agreement as a condition of receiving any Government funding for education purposes. The clause is linked to the repeal of the Education Grants Act 1973. That Act has been overtaken by a number of developments at both the Commonwealth and State levels and is being replaced by this clause. Clause 5.2.14 is a general section authorising the Minister to make Orders that are required, permitted or authorised to be made for the purpose of the Bill. The clause relies on other clauses to require, permit or authorise an Order being made. Clause 5.2.15 is a general section authorising the Minister to fix fees that are required, permitted or authorised to be made for the purpose of the Bill. PART 5.3--SECRETARY'S FUNCTIONS AND POWERS This Part contains some of the Secretary's powers and functions under the Bill. Other powers and functions are in Part 2.4 dealing with the Government teaching service, under the Public Administration Act 2004, in Part 5.8 concerning the appointment of authorised officers, and membership of various education statutory authorities. Other Acts, such as the Financial Management Act 1994, impose further functions on the Secretary. Clause 5.3.1 sets out the Secretary's powers of employment, and reflects the current position under the Public Administration Act 2004 and in respect of staff under the VQA Act, VCAA Act, and for the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission and Adult Community and Further Education Board. The Secretary has separate employment powers under Part 2.4 in respect of the Government teaching service. 48

 


 

Clause 5.3.2 and makes the Secretary responsible for implementing policies or decisions of the Minister or Victorian Skills Commission under Part 3.1. Clause 5.3.3 updates the Secretary's delegation powers in a consistent manner across the Bill and in sub-clause (3) empowers a school council to sub- delegate employment powers to a sub-committee. The Secretary's current delegation powers are in section 4(12) and 5A(3) of the Education Act 1958 and section 77 of the Teaching Service Act 1981 and 20(4) of the Vocational Education and Training Act 1990. Clause 5.3.4 repeats section 9 of the Education Act 1958 and enables the Secretary to request a criminal record check without a person's consent. Clause 5.3.5 authorises the Secretary to conduct a review of the effectiveness and efficiency of a school council. PART 5.4--WORKPLACE LEARNING Division 1--Work Experience This Division deals with work experience and workplace learning for students. Work experience mainly involves year 9 and 10 students in short-term industry placements, which broaden their experience and understanding of the world of work and career opportunities. Workplace learning involves pupils in structured on-the-job training during which they are expected to master a designated set of skills and competencies, related to courses accredited under Chapter 4. The details of both work experience and workplace learning is provided in Ministerial Orders. The sections reflect current practice and have recently been updated. No significant changes have been made to the current sections. Division 2--Practical Placement This Division deals with practical placement agreements for students, and accommodates the Workplace Relations Amendment (Work Choices) Act 2005. The Division provides that students do not receive remuneration and rely on the vocation education provisions of that Act so as to provide an incentive to employers to provide work experience to these students. 49

 


 

Division 3--Minimum Terms and Conditions for Students This Division deals with rates of pay for students under practical placement agreements. PART 5.5--APPRENTICES Divisions 1 to 4 Divisions 1 to 4 deals with apprenticeships, training schemes and training contracts and the role of the Victorian Skills Commission in those matters. Division 5--Approved Training Agents Clauses in this Division authorise the appointment of approved training agents by the Minister, rather than the Governor in Council. They deal with the appointment of approved training agents, delegations to them and a review of their decisions. Division 6--General This Division requires the Victorian Skills Commission to keep a register of apprentices, authorise the Commission to pay apprentices a subsidy to attend courses at remote places and the power for the Commission to charge a fee for certificates. PART 5.6--VOLUNTEER WORKERS COMPENSATION This part repeats sections 34A to 34I of the Education Act 1958. It deals with the compensation for personal injuries and compensation for damage to property to volunteers who assist in school work and approved community work. PART 5.7--SCHOLARSHIPS Clause 5.7.1 deals with scholarships founded by persons in connection with any Government schools. It repeats section 31 of the Education Act 1958 which sets out what the moneys may be used for. A new paragraph (d) has been added to deal with situations where the scholarship enabled a student to undertake a particular course or attend a post school location and the course is no longer available or the post school location is closed. The new paragraph (d) provides that the Minister may direct the scholarship can be used for another location. Clause 5.7.2 sets out the Minister's powers to grant scholarships subject to the regulations. 50

 


 

PART 5.8--ENFORCEMENT This Part sets out standard provisions for the appointment, identification and powers of authorised officers for the purpose of the Act. PART 5.9--GENERAL Clause 5.9.1 repeats section 20(7) of the VET Act 1990, and applies it consistently across the Bill, so as to clarify that matters can be delegated to a person who is required to advise the person making the delegation, before the power in the delegation can be exercised. Clause 5.9.2 repeats section 19 of the Education Act 1958. This section provides that lands which on 1/1/1873 had been granted by the Crown or reserved by the Crown for school purposes may, subject to Act No. 391, be sold by the denominational body and the proceeds applied as the body sees fit. The main purpose of section 19 was to increase the powers of trustees of non-Government schools on Crown lands to enable them to sell the lands. Clause 5.9.3 sets out for the purposes of section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975 the intention of clauses 2.2.2, 2.3.31 and 2.4.22 to limit the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of Victoria to entertain legal actions in respect of the matters in those clauses. PART 5.10--DELEGATED LEGISLATION Clause 5.10.1 is a general regulation making power and empowers regulations to also be made for any matters listed in Schedule 5. Clause 5.10.2 provides for the scope of regulations. Clause 5.10.3 is a power for the Governor in Council to make Orders. Clause 5.10.4 is a power to make Ministerial Orders for matters previously mentioned in the Bill, and mentions that Orders may also be made for any matters listed in Schedule 6. Clause 5.10.5 repeats section 11(5) of the Teaching Service Act 1981 to enable Orders in respect of the Teaching Service to be retrospective in operation. This is necessary to enable salary increases and other entitlements to be awarded from a date before the making of the Order. 51

 


 

Clause 5.10.6 requires any Order relating to the suspension or expulsion of students in Government schools to be tabled before, and subject to disallowance by, Parliament. CHAPTER 6--REPEALS, AMENDMENTS, SAVINGS AND TRANSITIONALS This Chapter provides the repeals, consequential amendments and transitional provisions consequent on the new and re-enacted provisions in the Bill. 52

 


 

 


[Index] [Search] [Download] [Bill] [Help]