Glasgow City Council v Marshall 67

[2000] UKHL 5; [2000] 1 All ER 641; [2000] ICR 196; [2000] 1 WLR 333; [2000] IRLR 272

House of Lords

United Kingdom

3rd February, 2000

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text	Citation Index
Scottish Water v Edgar (EQUAL PAY - material factor defence)	[2024] EAT 32	England and Wales Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom - England and Wales	6 Mar 2024	BAILII
CSC Computer Science Ltd v Hampson (EQUAL PAY)	[2023] EAT 88	England and Wales Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom - England and Wales	15 Jun 2023	BAILII	1
Department of Justice and Teresa Marie McGrath	[2021] NICA 44	Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	2 Jul 2021	BAILII
Walker v Co-Operative Group Ltd	[2020] EWCA Civ 1075	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	14 Aug 2020	BAILII
McGrath v Department of Justice (Discrimination - Age Discrimination - Equal Pay Discrimination - Sex)	[2019] NIIT 06490_17IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	25 Jul 2019	BAILII
Mercer v C & H Jefferson Solicitors (Discrimination - Equal Pay)	[2019] NIIT 01083_15IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	22 May 2019	BAILII
Lord Chancellor v McCloud	[2018] EWCA Civ 2844; [2019] ICR 1489	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	20 Dec 2018	BAILII	7
Nesbitt v The Pallet Centre Ltd (Discrimination - Equal Pay Discrimination - Sex Breach of Contract Unauthorised Deduction of Wages Unfair Dismissal)	[2018] NIIT 00304_16IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	17 Aug 2018	BAILII
Graysons Restaurants Ltd v Jones	[2017] UKEAT 0277_16_2811	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	7 Nov 2017	BAILII	1
Paczkowska & Golygowska v Avoca Handweavers (NI) Ltd	[2017] NIIT 01128_15IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	1 Feb 2017	BAILII
Naeem v Secretary of State for Justice	[2015] EWCA Civ 1264; [2016] ICR 289	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	9 Dec 2015	BAILII	4
McFarland v Dungannon and South Tyrone Bor	[2014] NIIT 1781_13IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	11 Jun 2014	BAILII
R (on the application of Unison) v Lord Chancellor	[2014] EWHC 218 (Admin); [2014] ICR 498	High Court of England and Wales	United Kingdom - England and Wales	7 Feb 2014	BAILII	10
Calmac Ferries Ltd v Wallace (Equal Pay Act : Material factor defence and justification)	[2013] UKEAT 0014_13_2210	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	22 Oct 2013	BAILII
Haq v The Audit Commission	[2012] EWCA Civ 1621	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	6 Dec 2012	BAILII	1
Council of the City of Sunderland v Brennan	[2012] EWCA Civ 413	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	3 Apr 2012	BAILII	3
– 1 February 2012 Decision	[2012] FWAFB 1000	Fair Work Australia	Australia	1 Feb 2012	AustLII	9
McPolin v Department of Finance & Person Department of Finance & Person	[2012] NIIT 00215_09IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	1 Feb 2012	BAILII
Secretary Of State For Justice (Sued As National Offenders Management Service) v Bowling (Equal Pay Act : Material factor defence and justification)	[2011] UKEAT 0297_11_2911	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	29 Nov 2011	BAILII
Secretary of State for Justice (Sued as National Offenders Management Service) v Bowling (Equal Pay Act : Material factor defence and justification)	[2011] UKEAT 0279_11_2911	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	29 Nov 2011	BAILII
Skills Development Scotland Co Ltd v Buchanan (Equal Pay Act : Material factor defence and justification)	[2011] UKEAT 0042_10_2505	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	25 May 2011	BAILII
Audit Commission v Haq	[2011] UKEAT 0123_10_1803	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	18 Mar 2011	BAILII	1
McLaughlin v Capita Business Services Limit	[2010] NIIT 00118_10IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	1 Feb 2011	BAILII
McLaughlin v University of Ulster	[2010] NIIT 04767_09IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	1 Feb 2011	BAILII
Newcastle upon Tyne NHS Hospitals Trust v Armstrong	[2010] UKEAT 0069_09_2202; [2010] ICR 674	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	22 Feb 2010	BAILII	8
Gibson v Sheffield City Council	[2010] EWCA Civ 63; [2010] IRLR 311; [2010] ICR 708	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	10 Feb 2010	BAILII	10
Wilson v Health and Safety Executive	[2009] EWCA Civ 1074; [2010] IRLR 59; [2010] ICR 302	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	20 Oct 2009	BAILII	7
Hamilton v Department of Finance & Personnel	[2009] NIIT 123_08IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	29 Jun 2009	BAILII
Hartlepool Borough Council v Llewellyn	[2009] UKEAT 0006_08_2406; [2009] IRLR 796; [2009] ICR 1426	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	24 Jun 2009	BAILII	12
Murphy v Northern Ireland Assembly Comm	[2009] NIIT 1504_07IT	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	11 Mar 2009	BAILII
Sheffield City Council v Crosby Ors	[2009] UKEAT 0303_08_1702	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	17 Feb 2009	BAILII
Dolphin	[2008] UKEAT 0007_08_1509; [2009] IRLR 168	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	15 Sep 2008	BAILII	3
Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council v Bainbridge (No 2)	[2008] EWCA Civ 885; [2009] ICR 133; [2008] IRLR 776	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	29 Jul 2008	BAILII	43
Baines v Blackpool Borough Council	[2007] UKEAT 0428_07_1812	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	18 Dec 2007	BAILII
Grundy v British Airways Plc	[2007] EWCA Civ 1020; [2008] IRLR 74	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	23 Oct 2007	BAILII	30
Middlesbrough Borough Council v Surtees	[2007] UKEAT 0077_07_1707; [2007] IRLR 869; [2007] ICR 1644	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	17 Jul 2007	BAILII	13
Cumbria County Council v Dow (No 1)	[2007] UKEAT 0148_06_2405; [2008] IRLR 91	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	24 May 2007	BAILII	11
South Tyneside Metropolitan Borough Council v Anderson	[2007] UKEAT 0684_05_2603	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	26 Mar 2007	BAILII
Tyne & Wear Passenger Transport Executive (t/a Nexus) v Best	[2006] UKEAT 0627_05_2112	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	21 Dec 2006	BAILII
Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council v Bainbridge	[2006] UKEAT 0135_06_1511; [2007] IRLR 91	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	15 Nov 2006	BAILII	11
Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council v Bainbridge	[2006] UKEAT 0135_06_1610	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	16 Oct 2006	BAILII
Cheshire & Wirral Partnership NHS v Abbott	[2006] EWCA Civ 523; [2006] ICR 1267; [2006] IRLR 546	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	4 Apr 2006	BAILII	6
Villalba v Merrill Lynch & Co Inc	[2006] UKEAT 0223_05_3103; [2007] ICR 469; [2006] IRLR 437	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	31 Mar 2006	BAILII	42
London Borough of Newham v Jacklin	[2006] UKEAT 0508_05_2202	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	22 Feb 2006	BAILII
Armstrong v Newcastle upon Tyne NHS Hospital Trust	[2005] EWCA Civ 1608; [2006] IRLR 124	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	21 Dec 2005	BAILII	40
Sharp v Caledonia Group Services Ltd	[2005] UKEAT 0041_05_0111; [2006] IRLR 4; [2006] ICR 218	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	1 Nov 2005	BAILII	3
Cheshire & Wirral Partnership NHS Trust v S Abbott & 30 Others	[2005] UKEAT 0353_05_1309	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	13 Sep 2005	BAILII
Home Office v Bailey	[2005] UKEAT 0706_04_2907	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	29 Jul 2005	BAILII
Chadwick v Morton Newspapers	[2005] NIIT 1776_00	Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	10 Jun 2005	BAILII
Chadwick v Morton Newspapers	[2005] NIFET 1776_00	Fair Employment Tribunal Northern Ireland	United Kingdom - Northern Ireland	10 Jun 2005	BAILII
Home Office v Bailey	[2005] EWCA Civ 327; [2005] ICR 1057; [2005] IRLR 369	England and Wales Court of Appeal - Civil Division	United Kingdom - England and Wales	22 Mar 2005	BAILII	10
Armstrong v Newcastle Upon Tyne NHS Hospital Trust	[2004] UKEAT 0158_04_2211	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	22 Nov 2004	BAILII
Pallett v Pent Valley Foundation School	[2004] UKEAT 0820_03_2807	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	28 Jul 2004	BAILII
Home Office v Bailey	[2004] UKEAT 0060_04_2707	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	27 Jul 2004	BAILII
Prebon Marshall Yamane (UK) Ltd v Rose	[2004] UKEAT 1002_02_0206	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	2 Jun 2004	BAILII
Paterson v London Borough Of Islington	[2004] UKEAT 0347_03_2304	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	23 Apr 2004	BAILII
Ministry Of Defence v Armstrong	[2004] UKEAT 1239_02_0704; [2004] IRLR 672	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	7 Apr 2004	BAILII	18
Charles v Department of Environment Transport & Regions	[2003] UKEAT 0454_03_1612	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	16 Dec 2003	BAILII
Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration v Fernandez	[2003] UKEAT 0137_03_0509; [2004] ICR 123	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	5 Sep 2003	BAILII	2
King's College London v Clark	[2003] UKEAT 1049_02_0509	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	5 Sep 2003	BAILII
Aintree Hospitals NHS Trust v Reynolds	[2003] UKEAT 0667_02_0209	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	2 Sep 2003	BAILII
Christie v John E Haith Ltd	[2003] UKEAT 0793_02_2003; [2003] IRLR 670	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	20 Mar 2003	BAILII	1
Secretary of State for The Home Office v Ord	[2003] UKEAT 0652_01_1401	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	14 Jan 2003	BAILII
Carlisle City Council v Bulman	[2002] UKEAT 1120_01_0212	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	2 Dec 2002	BAILII
Uppingham School Retirement Benefits Scheme for Non-Teaching Staff v Shillcock	[2002] EWHC 641 (Ch); [2002] IRLR 702; [2002] OPLR 241	High Court of England and Wales	United Kingdom - England and Wales	19 Apr 2002	BAILII	3
William Ball Ltd v Wood	[2002] UKEAT 89_01_2102	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	21 Feb 2002	BAILII

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title	Citation(s)	Author	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text		Citation Index
Reviewing the Suitability of Affirmative Action and the Inherent Requirements of the Job as Grounds of Justification to Equal Pay Claims in Terms Of the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 (Vol 21)	[2018] PER 17	Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2018	SAFLII

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text	Citation Index
Shilliday v Smith	[1998] SC 72		United Kingdom - Scotland	circa 1998		2
Tyldesley v TML Plastics Ltd	[1995] UKEAT 1044_93_2303; [1996] IRLR 395; [1996] ICR 356	Employment Appeals Tribunal	United Kingdom	23 Mar 1995	BAILII	13
Rainey v Greater Glasgow Health Board	[1987] UKHL 16; [1987] AC 224; [1987] 1 All ER 65; [1987] ICR 129; [1987] IRLR 26; [1986] 3 WLR 1017; [1987] SLT 146; [1987] SC (HL) 1	House of Lords	United Kingdom - Scotland	27 Nov 1986	BAILII	66

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback