LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite

Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Port Nelson Ltd v Commerce Commission   flag  171

[1996] NZCA 230; [1996] 3 NZLR 554; (1996) 5 NZBLC 99,382; (1996) 7 TCLR 217
Court of Appeal of New Zealand
New Zealand
3rd July, 1996

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index † 
Commerce Commission v Woolworths Ltd [2008] NZCA 276; (2008) 8 NZBLC 102,336; [2009] NZCCLR 12; (2008) 12 TCLR 194 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 1 Aug 2008 NZLII flag 117
Air New Zealand v Commerce Commission (No 6) [2004] NZHC 1010; (2004) 11 TCLR 347 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 17 Sep 2004 NZLII flag 62
Transpower New Zealand Ltd v Todd Energy Ltd [2007] NZCA 302 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 20 Jul 2007 NZLII flag 57
Commissioner of Inland Revenue v BNZ Investments Ltd [2001] NZCA 184; [2002] 1 NZLR 450; (2001) 20 NZTC 17,103 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 22 May 2001 NZLII flag 43
ANZCO Foods Waitara Ltd v AFFCO New Zealand Ltd [2005] NZCA 166; [2006] 3 NZLR 351; (2005) 2 NZCCLR 759; (2005) 11 TCLR 278; (2005) 6 NZCPR 448 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 23 Jun 2005 NZLII flag 26
NZME Ltd v Commerce Commission [2018] NZCA 389; [2018] 3 NZLR 715 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 26 Sep 2018 NZLII flag 15
Carter Holt Harvey Building Products Group Ltd v Commerce Commission [2001] NZCA 298; (2001) 10 TCLR 247 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 5 Nov 2001 NZLII flag 14
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd [2016] FCAFC 42; (2016) 244 FCR 190; (2016) 330 ALR 230 Federal Court of Australia Australia - Commonwealth 21 Mar 2016 AustLII flag 12
Wall v Fairfax New Zealand Ltd [2018] NZHC 104; [2018] 2 NZLR 471; (2018) 11 HRNZ 373 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 12 Feb 2018 NZLII flag 11
Carter Holt Harvey Building Products Group Ltd v Commerce Commission [2004] UKPC 37; (2004) 2 NZCCLR 158; (2004) 11 TCLR 200 Privy Council New Zealand 14 Jul 2004 BAILII flag 9
Todd Pohokura Ltd v Shell Exploration NZ Ltd [2015] NZCA 71 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 20 Mar 2015 NZLII flag 7
Commerce Commission v Telecom Corporation of New Zealand and Telecom New Zealand Ltd [2009] NZCA 338; (2009) 12 TCLR 457; [2010] NZCCLR 10 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 4 Aug 2009 NZLII flag 7
Dwyer v Movements International Movers (WA) Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 75 Supreme Court of Western Australia - Court of Appeal Australia - Western Australia 3 Feb 2000 AustLII flag 5
Turners & Growers Ltd v Zespri Group Ltd HC Auckland CIV 2009-404-004392 [2011] NZHC 913; (2011) 13 TCLR 286 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 12 Aug 2011 NZLII flag 3
Wall v Fairfax New Zealand Ltd [2017] NZHRRT 17; (2017) 11 HRNZ 165 New Zealand Human Rights Review Tribunal New Zealand 12 May 2017 NZLII flag 2
Telecom Corporation of New Zealand Ltd v Commerce Commission [2001] NZCA 311; (2001) 10 TCLR 182 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 17 Sep 2001 NZLII flag 2
Robinson v Complaints Assessment Committee of the Teaching Council of Aotearoa New Zealand [2022] NZCA 350 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 3 Aug 2022 NZLII flag
Evans [2022] NZCorC 9 New Zealand 26 Jan 2022 NZLII flag
Samatua [2021] NZCorC 149 New Zealand 13 Sep 2021 NZLII flag
Otago Regional Council v Alliance Group Ltd [2020] NZHC 628 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 24 Mar 2020 NZLII flag
Plenitude Ltd trading as Khandallah Bottle-O [2019] NZDLCWN 1654 New Zealand 7 Oct 2019 NZLII flag
Canterbury Regional Council v Selwyn Quarries Ltd [2019] NZHC 434 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 13 Mar 2019 NZLII flag
Tennex Capital Ltd and San-i-pak Ltd [2018] NZComComm 25 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 19 Dec 2018 NZLII flag
Trade Me Ltd and Limelight Software Ltd [2018] NZComComm 1 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 8 Mar 2018 NZLII flag
Investigation report on Sky TV contracts (original un-numbered) [2013] NZComComm 54 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 8 Oct 2013 NZLII flag
Bertelsmann SE & Co KGaA and Pearson plc [2013] NZComComm 6 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 19 Mar 2013 NZLII flag
Bligh Finance Ltd and Hire Equipment Group Ltd [2013] NZComComm 2 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 21 Feb 2013 NZLII flag
Vodafone New Zealand Ltd and TelstraClear Ltd [2012] NZComComm 33 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 29 Oct 2012 NZLII flag
Joint venture between Television New Zealand Ltd and Sky Network Television Ltd, Igloo (original un-numbered) [2012] NZComComm 50 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 16 May 2012 NZLII flag
Ian David Penny and Gary John Hooper v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2011] NZSCTrans 19 New Zealand 27 Jun 2011 NZLII flag
Bay Cities Real Estate Ltd v Re/Max New Zealand Ltd HC Napier CIV 2010-441-134 [2011] NZHC 539 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 8 Jun 2011 NZLII flag
Todd Pohokura Ltd v Shell Exploration NZ Ltd HC Wellington CIV 2006-485-1600 [2010] NZHC 1134 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 13 Jul 2010 NZLII flag
Tomarata Sand Ltd and Coastal Resources Ltd; Decision No 696 [2010] NZComComm 11 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 25 Jun 2010 NZLII flag
Commerce Commission v Telecom [2010] NZSCTrans 14 New Zealand 21 Jun 2010 NZLII flag
Todd Pohokura Ltd v Shell Exploration NZ Ltd HC WN Civ 2006 485 1600 [2009] NZHC 1013 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 12 Aug 2009 NZLII flag
David Ferrier and/or New Zealand Woolscourers Ltd and Cavalier Wool Holdings Ltd and Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd; Decision No 666 [2009] NZComComm 5 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Mar 2009 NZLII flag
ISS Holdings NZ Ltd and Chubb New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 660 [2008] NZComComm 30 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Nov 2008 NZLII flag
Salmon Smolt New Zealand Ltd and National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research Ltd; Decision No 659 [2008] NZComComm 29 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Oct 2008 NZLII flag
Shell New Zealand Ltd and Mobil Oil New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 655 [2008] NZComComm 25 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Oct 2008 NZLII flag
Southern Cross Health Trust and Aorangi Hospital Ltd; Decision No 650 [2008] NZComComm 21 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 Sep 2008 NZLII flag
CSR Building Products (NZ) Ltd and Ross Roofing Ltd, Rosscrete Roofing Tiles Ltd and Ross Brick & Pavers Ltd; Decision No 648 [2008] NZComComm 19 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 27 Aug 2008 NZLII flag
Redeal Ltd and Egley Electrical Co Ltd and Egley Electrical Petone Ltd; Decision No 645 [2008] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Jun 2008 NZLII flag
Flint Group Holdings SARL and Siegwerk New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 642 [2008] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 14 May 2008 NZLII flag
Vita New Zealand Ltd and Pacific Brands Holdings (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 641 [2008] NZComComm 12 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Apr 2008 NZLII flag
New Zealand Investment Holdings Lmited and RX Plastics Ltd; Decision No 639 [2008] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 3 Apr 2008 NZLII flag
DFS Group Ltd and The Nuance Group; Decision No 638 [2008] NZComComm 9 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Mar 2008 NZLII flag
Sumitomo Forestry Co Ltd and Carter Holt Harvey Ltd (Building Supplies Division); Decision No 637 [2008] NZComComm 8 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Mar 2008 NZLII flag
Air Liquide New Zealand Ltd and ASCOGAS Ltd; Decision No 633 [2008] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 13 Feb 2008 NZLII flag
Provenco Group Ltd and Cadmus Technology Ltd; Decision No 632 [2008] NZComComm 3 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 Feb 2008 NZLII flag
Pacific Radiology Ltd and Wellington Radiology Ltd; Decision No 631 [2007] NZComComm 29 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Dec 2007 NZLII flag
Commerce Commission v Bay of Plenty Electricity Ltd HC WN Civ-2001-485-917 [2007] NZHC 1452 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 13 Dec 2007 NZLII flag
A & R Whicoulls Holdings Group Pty Ltd and Borders New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 630 [2007] NZComComm 28 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Nov 2007 NZLII flag
Cavalier Corporation Ltd and Norman Ellison Holdings Ltd; Decision No 628 [2007] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 14 Nov 2007 NZLII flag
Transpacific Industries Group (NZ) Ltd (TPI) and Ironbridge Capital Pty Ltd (Ironbridge); Decision No 622, Decision No 623, Decision No 624, Decision No 625 [2007] NZComComm 25 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 31 Oct 2007 NZLII flag
Schering-Plough Corporation and Organon Biosciences N v; Decision No 621 [2007] NZComComm 24 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 Oct 2007 NZLII flag
Southern Cross Health Trust and QE Hospital Ltd; Decision No 620 [2007] NZComComm 23 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Sep 2007 NZLII flag
New Zealand Post Ltd v Salmat International Pty Ltd; Decision [2007] NZComComm 617 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Sep 2007 NZLII flag
Transpacific Technical Services (NZ) Ltd and Medi-Chem Waster Services Ltd; Decision No 616 [2007] NZComComm 19 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Aug 2007 NZLII flag
ST Cigar Group Holding BV and British American Tobacco Plc; Decision No 614 [2007] NZComComm 17 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 17 Aug 2007 NZLII flag
Transpacific Technical Services (NZ) Ltd and Medi-Chem Waste Services Ltd; Decision No 613 [2007] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 15 Aug 2007 NZLII flag
Foodstuffs (Auckland) Ltd, Foodstuffs (Wellington) Co-operative Society Ltd, and Foodstuffs South Island Ltd; and (seperately) Woolworths Ltd and The Warehouse Group Ltd; Decision No 606 and Decision No 607 [2007] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 8 Jun 2007 NZLII flag
Transpacific Industries Group (NZ) Ltd and Ironbridge Capital Pty Ltd; Decision No 604 [2007] NZComComm 8 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 May 2007 NZLII flag
Carter Holt Harvey Ltd and Lakesawn Lumber Ltd; Decision No 602 [2007] NZComComm 6 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 9 May 2007 NZLII flag
Department of Labour v Fletcher Concrete and Infrastructure ta Stresscrete (NZDC Papakura) [2007] NZHSE 4; [2007] NZHSE 17 New Zealand Health and Safety in Employment New Zealand 26 Mar 2007 NZLII flag
Goodman Fielder Ltd and River Mill Bakeries Ltd; Decision No 599 [2007] NZComComm 3 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 15 Mar 2007 NZLII flag
Boc Ltd and Shell New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 597 [2007] NZComComm 1 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 21 Feb 2007 NZLII flag
Owens Corning and Compagnie De Saint Gobain; Decision No 596 [2006] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Dec 2006 NZLII flag
Fulton Hogan Ltd and GJ Beynon Contracting Ltd; Decision No 595 [2006] NZComComm 25 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 19 Dec 2006 NZLII flag
Solid Energy New Zealand Ltd and Newvale Coal Co Ltd; Decision No 592 [2006] NZComComm 22 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Nov 2006 NZLII flag
Toll Owens Ltd and John Ray Ltd; Decision No 590 [2006] NZComComm 20 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 Oct 2006 NZLII flag
CRBF Ltd and Carter Holt Harvey Ltd; Decision No 589 [2006] NZComComm 19 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 Oct 2006 NZLII flag
Commerce v Koppers HC Ak Civ 2005-404-2080 [2006] NZHC 1168 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 4 Oct 2006 NZLII flag
Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd and Feltex Carpets Ltd; Decision No 587 [2006] NZComComm 17 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 31 Aug 2006 NZLII flag
Lion Nathan Ltd and Independent Liquor (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 586 [2006] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Aug 2006 NZLII flag
GE Fleet New Zealand and Custom Fleet (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 584 [2006] NZComComm 14 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 Jul 2006 NZLII flag
Visy Industrial Plastics (NZ) Ltd and Alto Holdings Ltd; Decision No 583 [2006] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Jun 2006 NZLII flag
Portacom New Zealand Ltd and Rhino Group Ltd; Decision No 577 [2006] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 Apr 2006 NZLII flag
Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd and Kapiti Fine Foods Ltd and United Milk Ltd; Decision No 574 [2006] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Feb 2006 NZLII flag
Sky Network Television Ltd and Prime Television New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 573 [2006] NZComComm 3 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 8 Feb 2006 NZLII flag
Valley Diagnostic Laboratories Ltd and Wellington Pathology Ltd; Decision No 572 [2006] NZComComm 2 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 31 Jan 2006 NZLII flag
GE Finance Retail Services Ltd, Pacific Retail Finance Ltd, Montreal Financial Services Ltd and Simply Insurance Ltd; Decision No 571 [2006] NZComComm 1 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 18 Jan 2006 NZLII flag
Energy Market Services Ltd and THe Marketplace Co Ltd; Decision No 569 [2005] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Dec 2005 NZLII flag
Reckitt Benckiser PLC and Boots Healthcare International Ltd; Decision No 567 [2005] NZComComm 24 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Nov 2005 NZLII flag
Gallagher Group Ltd and Greyson Gates Ltd; Decision No 566 [2005] NZComComm 23 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Nov 2005 NZLII flag
Chief Executive of the Department of Corrections v W HC Ble Cri-2005-406-006 [2005] NZHC 304 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 29 Nov 2005 NZLII flag
Essilor New Zealand Ltd and Optical Laboratories NZ Ltd; Decision No 565 [2005] NZComComm 22 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Nov 2005 NZLII flag
Essilor New Zealand Ltd and Prolab (Wellington) Ltd; Decision No 564 [2005] NZComComm 21 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Nov 2005 NZLII flag
Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd and New Zealand Dairy Foods Ltd; Decision No 562 [2005] NZComComm 19 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 9 Nov 2005 NZLII flag
Bluebird Foods Ltd and Hansells (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 560 [2005] NZComComm 17 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 Oct 2005 NZLII flag
New Zealand Diagnostic Group Ltd and Sonic Healthcare (New Zealand) Ltd; Decision No 559 [2005] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 29 Sep 2005 NZLII flag
Fletcher Concrete and Infrastructure Ltd and W Stevenson and Sons Ltd; Decision No 558 [2005] NZComComm 558 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 15 Sep 2005 NZLII flag
Canwest Radioworks Ltd and Radio FM Licences in Northland; Decision No 557 [2005] NZComComm 14 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 31 Aug 2005 NZLII flag
Pernod Ricard SA and Allied Domecq PLC; Decision No 553 [2005] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 13 Jul 2005 NZLII flag
Fortune Brands, Inc and Pernod Ricard SA; Decision No 552 [2005] NZComComm 9 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 8 Jul 2005 NZLII flag
Red Bus Ltd and Leopard Coachlines; Decision No 551 [2005] NZComComm 8 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Jun 2005 NZLII flag
Provet NZ Pty Ltd and National Veterinary Supplies Ltd; Decision No 549 [2005] NZComComm 6 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 May 2005 NZLII flag
Gallagher Holdings Ltd and Tru-Test Corporation Ltd; Decision No 545 [2005] NZComComm 2 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Feb 2005 NZLII flag
Southern Cross Health Trust and Auckland Surgical Centre Ltd; Decision No 546 [2005] NZComComm 3 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 17 Feb 2005 NZLII flag
Sanford Ltd and Simunovich Fisheries Ltd; Decision No 544 [2005] NZComComm 1 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 26 Jan 2005 NZLII flag
Carter Holt Harvey Ltd and Tenon Ltd; Decision No 543 [2004] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 21 Dec 2004 NZLII flag
Vector Ltd and NGC Holdings Ltd; Decision No 540 [2004] NZComComm 23 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Dec 2004 NZLII flag
Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd and National Foods Ltd; Decision No 542 [2004] NZComComm 25 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 9 Dec 2004 NZLII flag
Vehicle Testing New Zealand Ltd and On Road New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 539 [2004] NZComComm 22 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 17 Nov 2004 NZLII flag
Southern Cross Oxford Hospital Ltd and The Oxford Clinic; Decision No 537 [2004] NZComComm 537 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 Nov 2004 NZLII flag
iSoft NZ Ltd and Hewlett-Packard New Zealand; Decision No 535 [2004] NZComComm 18 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 29 Sep 2004 NZLII flag
Port of Tauranga Ltd; Decision No 533 [2004] NZComComm 533 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Sep 2004 NZLII flag
ABF Overseas Ltd and New Zealand Food Industries Ltd; Decision No 532 [2004] NZComComm 15 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 27 Aug 2004 NZLII flag
Gallagher Holdings Ltd and Tru-Test Corporation Ltd; Decision No 531 [2004] NZComComm 14 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 26 Aug 2004 NZLII flag
Bondor New Zealand Ltd and Long International Ltd; Decision No 530 [2004] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 22 Jul 2004 NZLII flag
Visypet (NZ) Ltd and Visy Industrial Plastics (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 527 [2004] NZComComm 8 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Jun 2004 NZLII flag
Visy Industrial Plastics (NZ) Ltd and ACI Operations NZ Ltd; Decision No 524 [2004] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 May 2004 NZLII flag
CB Norwood Distributors Ltd and CNH Australia Pty Ltd; Decision No 522 [2004] NZComComm 522 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 18 May 2004 NZLII flag
Skycity Entertainment Group Ltd and Aspinall (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 523 [2004] NZComComm 6 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 18 May 2004 NZLII flag
Atlas Group Holdings Ltd and Southward Engineering Ltd; Decision No 520 [2004] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 May 2004 NZLII flag
Commerce Commission v Ophthalmological Society of New Zealand HC Wellington CIV-1997-485-34 [2004] NZHC 1224 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 1 Mar 2004 NZLII flag
Pacific Radiology Ltd and Wakefield Radiology Ltd; Decision No 518 [2004] NZComComm 2 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 26 Feb 2004 NZLII flag
Electricity Governance Board Ltd - Decision No 473 [2002] NZComComm 23 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Sep 2002 NZLII flag
Boral Besser Masonry Ltd (now Boral Masonry Ltd) v ACCC M1/2002 [2002] HCATrans 250 High Court of Australia Australia - Commonwealth 22 May 2002 AustLII flag
Lowe Corporation Ltd and Colyer Mair Ltd; Decision No 440 [2001] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 27 Jul 2001 NZLII flag
Carter Holt Harvey Ltd and Central North Island Forestry Partnership; Decision No 426 [2001] NZComComm 12 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 5 Jul 2001 NZLII flag
Computershare Registry Services Ltd and BT Portfolio Services Ltd; Decision No 437 [2001] NZComComm 23 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Jun 2001 NZLII flag
Solid Energy New Zealand Ltd and Todd Coal Ltd; Decision No 432 [2001] NZComComm 18 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Jun 2001 NZLII flag
Newco and Merino New Zealand Ltd and Wrightson Ltd; Decision No 436 [2001] NZComComm 22 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 7 Jun 2001 NZLII flag
Fletcher Building Products Ltd and Carter Holt Harvey Doors; Decision No 430 [2001] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 31 May 2001 NZLII flag
McCains Foods (NZ) Ltd and Heinz Wattie's Ltd; Decision No 429 [2001] NZComComm 15 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 May 2001 NZLII flag
Steel and Tube Holdings Ltd and Fletcher Steel Ltd; Decision No 427 [2001] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 27 Apr 2001 NZLII flag
P & O Cold Logistics (NZ) Ltd and Eskimo Logistics Group Ltd; Decision No 418 [2001] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 16 Feb 2001 NZLII flag
James Hardie New Zealand Ltd and Long International Ltd; Decision No 412 [2000] NZComComm 31 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 15 Dec 2000 NZLII flag
Ruapehu Alpine Lifts Ltd and Turoa Ski Resorts Ltd (in receivership); Decision no 410 [2000] NZComComm 29 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 14 Nov 2000 NZLII flag
Mainland Products Ltd and Nelson Milk Co; Decision No 396 [2000] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 7 Jun 2000 NZLII flag
BP Amoco Plc and BurmahCastrol Plc; Decision No 394 [2000] NZComComm 14 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 26 May 2000 NZLII flag
CGU Plc and Norwich Union Plc; Decision No 391 [2000] NZComComm 11 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 9 May 2000 NZLII flag
PolarCup (NZ) Ltd and Carter Holt Harvey Plastic Products Division; Decision No 390 [2000] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Apr 2000 NZLII flag
Natural Gas Corporation Holdings Ltd and Transalta New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 387 [2000] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 17 Mar 2000 NZLII flag
Pacific Dunlop Holdings (NZ) Ltd and LWR Hosiery and Underwear Ltd and R & WH Symington Ltd; Decision No 383 [2000] NZComComm 3 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 29 Feb 2000 NZLII flag
Bidco and The BOC Group plc; Decision No 379 [1999] NZComComm 33 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Dec 1999 NZLII flag
UnitedNetworks Ltd and Orion New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 380 [1999] NZComComm 34 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Dec 1999 NZLII flag
Fletcher Challenge Steel Products Ltd and Steel and Tube Holdings Ltd; Decision No 378 [1999] NZComComm 32 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Dec 1999 NZLII flag
Teamtalk Ltd and Telecom New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 377 [1999] NZComComm 31 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 3 Dec 1999 NZLII flag
Fletcher Challenge Steel Products Ltd and Steel and Tube Holdings Ltd; Decision No 376 [1999] NZComComm 30 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 Nov 1999 NZLII flag
Spotless Services (NZ) Ltd and P & O Services (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 372 [1999] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 9 Sep 1999 NZLII flag
On Road New Zealand Ltd and Vehicle Testing New Zelaand Ltd; Decision No 370 [1999] NZComComm 24 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Aug 1999 NZLII flag
Tourism Holdings Ltd and Britz New Zealand Rentals Ltd and Backpacker Campervans Ltd; Decision No 368 [1999] NZComComm 22 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 13 Aug 1999 NZLII flag
Kalanda Enterprises Pty Ltd and Swan Metal Skirtings Pty Ltd; Decision No 367 [1999] NZComComm 21 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 13 Aug 1999 NZLII flag
Turners & Growers Ltd and United Flower Auction Ltd; Decision No 364 [1999] NZComComm 51 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 15 Jul 1999 NZLII flag
Ruapehu Alpine Lifts Ltd and Turoa Ski Resort Ltd; Decision No 357 [1999] NZComComm 11 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 14 Jun 1999 NZLII flag
Waste Management NZ Ltd and Waste Care Ltd; Decision No 355 [1999] NZComComm 9 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 14 May 1999 NZLII flag
Sigma Co Ltd and Amcal Chemists Marketing Ltd; Decision No 350 [1999] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Apr 1999 NZLII flag
UnitedNetworks Ltd and Transalta New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 345 [1999] NZComComm 41 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 Mar 1999 NZLII flag
Kroma Colour Prints Ltd and Zanda Laboratories Ltd; Decision No 346 [1999] NZComComm 42 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Mar 1999 NZLII flag
Alliant International New Zealand Ltd and Contact Energy Ltd; Decision No 339 [1999] NZComComm 36 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Feb 1999 NZLII flag
Transalta Corporation of Canada and Contact Energy Ltd; Decision No 340 [1999] NZComComm 37 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Feb 1999 NZLII flag
Eastbay Health Ltd and Western Bay Health Ltd; Decision No 331 [1998] NZComComm 17 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 19 Nov 1998 NZLII flag
Heinz-Wattie Ltd and Griffins Foods Ltd (Eta Foods Division); Decision No 327 [1998] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 7 Jul 1998 NZLII flag
Mainland Products Ltd and South Island Dairy Farmers Co-operative Ltd Decision No 324 [1998] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 May 1998 NZLII flag
Look Outdoor Ltd and Adshel Street Furniture Ltd; Decision No 321 [1998] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Mar 1998 NZLII flag
Carglass (NZ) Ltd and Smith & Smith Ltd; Decision No 319 [1998] NZComComm 5 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Mar 1998 NZLII flag
New Zealand Bus Ltd and Transportation Auckland Corporation Ltd; Decision No 318 [1998] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Feb 1998 NZLII flag
Wolters Kluwer NV and Reed Elsevier PLC; Decision No 315 [1998] NZComComm 1 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 29 Jan 1998 NZLII flag
Nuplex Industries Ltd and Australian Chemical Holdings Ltd; Decision No 314 [1997] NZComComm 31 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Dec 1997 NZLII flag
Mentec Ltd and Annett & Darling Ltd; Decision No 309 [1997] NZComComm 28 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 2 Oct 1997 NZLII flag
Purebred Jersey Breed Society (NZ) Inc v Jersey Breeders Association Inc HC Hamilton CP17/96 [1997] NZHC 2097 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 2 May 1997 NZLII flag
Tranzrich Travel Ltd and Guthreys Intercity Coach Services Ltd; Decision No 288 [1997] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 Apr 1997 NZLII flag

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index † 
"Trade Practices Act 1974 (CTH) and the Treatment of Cluster Markets in the Australian Telecommunications Industry, The" (2001) 25 Melbourne University Law Review 481 Goss, Adrian Australia circa 2001 AustLII flag 1
"Pragmatism and Cartel Prosecutions: Developments in the Law of Price Fixing in Lodge Real Estate Ltd v Commerce Commission" (2020) 26 Auckland University Law Review 320 Anyon-Peters, Caitlin New Zealand circa 2020 NZLII flag
"Local authority liability for development in areas subject to hazards" [2011] NZJlEnvLaw 10 (2011) 15 New Zealand Journal of Environmental Law 277 Harker, Julia New Zealand circa 2011 NZLII flag
"Merger Analysis of Failing or Exiting Firms Under the Substantive Lessening of Competition Threshold" (2010) 16 Canterbury Law Review 272 Berry, Mark N; Scott, Paul G New Zealand circa 2010 NZLII flag
"Gazing into the Crystal Ball: Improving the Evaluation of Uncertainty in New Zealand Merger Clearance Applications" (2009) 2 New Zealand Law Students Journal 95 Ronen, Lazarovitch New Zealand circa 2009 NZLII flag
"Facilitating and Regulating Commerce" [2002] VUWLawRw 35 White QC, Douglas New Zealand circa 2002 NZLII flag
"Predatory Conduct Under the Commerce Act 1986" [1998] VUWLawRw 31 Coull, David New Zealand circa 1998 NZLII flag
"Copyright Law and Moral Rights" (1997) 5 Waikato Law Review 83 Jones, Peter New Zealand circa 1997 NZLII flag

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name Provision
Trade Practices Act (Cth) s2, s3, s27, s29, s36, s46, s4E

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index † 
Waste Management NZ Ltd and Waste Care Ltd; Decision No 355 [1999] NZComComm 9 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 14 May 1999 NZLII flag
Sigma Co Ltd and Amcal Chemists Marketing Ltd; Decision No 350 [1999] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Apr 1999 NZLII flag
UnitedNetworks Ltd and Transalta New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 345 [1999] NZComComm 41 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 Mar 1999 NZLII flag
Kroma Colour Prints Ltd and Zanda Laboratories Ltd; Decision No 346 [1999] NZComComm 42 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Mar 1999 NZLII flag
Alliant International New Zealand Ltd and Contact Energy Ltd; Decision No 339 [1999] NZComComm 36 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Feb 1999 NZLII flag
Transalta Corporation of Canada and Contact Energy Ltd; Decision No 340 [1999] NZComComm 37 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Feb 1999 NZLII flag
Eastbay Health Ltd and Western Bay Health Ltd; Decision No 331 [1998] NZComComm 17 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 19 Nov 1998 NZLII flag
Heinz-Wattie Ltd and Griffins Foods Ltd (Eta Foods Division); Decision No 327 [1998] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 7 Jul 1998 NZLII flag
Mainland Products Ltd and South Island Dairy Farmers Co-operative Ltd Decision No 324 [1998] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 May 1998 NZLII flag
Look Outdoor Ltd and Adshel Street Furniture Ltd; Decision No 321 [1998] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Mar 1998 NZLII flag
Carglass (NZ) Ltd and Smith & Smith Ltd; Decision No 319 [1998] NZComComm 5 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Mar 1998 NZLII flag
New Zealand Bus Ltd and Transportation Auckland Corporation Ltd; Decision No 318 [1998] NZComComm 4 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Feb 1998 NZLII flag
Wolters Kluwer NV and Reed Elsevier PLC; Decision No 315 [1998] NZComComm 1 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 29 Jan 1998 NZLII flag
"Predatory Conduct Under the Commerce Act 1986" [1998] VUWLawRw 31 Coull, David New Zealand circa 1998 NZLII flag
Nuplex Industries Ltd and Australian Chemical Holdings Ltd; Decision No 314 [1997] NZComComm 31 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Dec 1997 NZLII flag
Mentec Ltd and Annett & Darling Ltd; Decision No 309 [1997] NZComComm 28 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 2 Oct 1997 NZLII flag
Purebred Jersey Breed Society (NZ) Inc v Jersey Breeders Association Inc HC Hamilton CP17/96 [1997] NZHC 2097 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 2 May 1997 NZLII flag
Tranzrich Travel Ltd and Guthreys Intercity Coach Services Ltd; Decision No 288 [1997] NZComComm 7 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 11 Apr 1997 NZLII flag
"Copyright Law and Moral Rights" (1997) 5 Waikato Law Review 83 Jones, Peter New Zealand circa 1997 NZLII flag
[1992] Atpr 41 circa 1997

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback