No. 65 of 2010
__________________
Victoria
No. 65 of 2010
[Assented to 28 September 2010]
ENDNOTES
Endnotes
[†] Minister's second reading speech—
Legislative Assembly: 12 August 2010
Legislative Council: 2 September 2010
The long title for the Bill for this Act was "A Bill for an Act to provide for safe marine operations in Victoria and to consequentially amend the Marine Act 1988 and other Acts and for other purposes."
INDEX
Subject |
Section |
---|---|
Act |
|
amendments to Marine Act 1988 |
375–393 |
amendments to other Acts |
418–420, Sch. 3 |
amendments to Transport (Compliance and Miscellaneous) Act 1983 |
|
application to types of voyages |
9 |
commencement |
2 |
Crown bound by |
13 |
interaction with Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 |
|
not to apply to defence force vessels |
10 |
objects |
14, 22 |
presumed to apply to vessels |
296 |
principles |
15–22 |
purpose |
1 |
regulations |
97–99, 299, 300, 309–312, 315, Sch. 2 |
repeal of Part 10.4, Schedule 3 |
421 |
repeal of section 315 |
315 |
savings, transitional provisions |
313–374 |
transport legislation within Transport Integration Act 2010 |
|
Activity exclusion zones |
208–210 |
Adverse publicity orders |
173 |
Appeals |
103, 114, 368–372 |
Arrest |
160 |
3, 102 |
|
|
|
Authorised persons |
|
by police to assist |
109 |
definitions |
103, 303 |
obstruction, hindrance of |
303 |
powers, duties regarding |
|
impounded, immobilised recreational vessels |
116 |
lights |
159 |
Boating activities |
|
exclusion zones |
208–210 |
exemptions from Act, rules |
203–207 |
transitional provision |
343 |
Boating facilities |
312 |
Bodies corporate |
284, 285 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
Certificates of competency |
|
acting without |
74 |
application |
77 |
breach of conditions of |
76 |
cancellation |
91, 93 |
conditions |
75, 78, 79 |
disqualification |
93 |
issue |
78 |
non-compliance with conditions of |
75 |
renewal |
77, 78 |
requirement to hold |
73 |
Safety Director's powers |
258, Sch. 1 |
suspension |
91, 93 |
transitional provisions |
360, 361 |
See also Local knowledge certificates |
|
Channel operators (def.) |
3 |
Channels (def.) |
3 |
See also Dredging |
|
Chief Commissioner of Police |
|
powers regarding |
|
disposal orders |
148, 149 |
forfeiture orders |
119–121, 123 |
impoundment, immobilisation of recreational vessels |
111, 113, 118, 120, 121, 123, 127 |
registration of recreational vessels |
124 |
270 |
|
sale, disposal of uncollected vessels, items |
144, 145, 147–149 |
Civil liability |
35 |
Codes of practice – Safety duties |
|
approval |
272 |
approved codes of practice (def.) |
3 |
availability |
275 |
consultation |
276 |
effect of |
277 |
effect of compliance with |
299 |
revisions |
273 |
revocation |
273, 274 |
tabling, disallowance |
278 |
waterway management |
219 |
|
|
Convention on the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea, 1972 |
|
Corresponding laws (def.) |
3 |
Crews |
|
acts tending to endanger |
88 |
application of Act to |
9 |
certificates of competency |
77, 78 |
required to have appropriate certificates |
73, 74 |
Safety Director's powers |
258, Sch. 1 |
|
|
Subject |
Section |
171 |
|
298 |
|
Defence force vessels |
10 |
Definitions |
3, 4, 5, 9, 30, 95, 98, 102, 103, 163, 171, 175, 183, 203, 211, 267, 287, 288, 303, 304, 306, 313, 332, 333, 334, 337, 338, 339, 357, 358 |
Director, Transport Safety See Safety Director |
|
Disciplinary action See Adverse publicity orders; Marine licences; Permissions |
|
Distress signals |
90 |
Dredging |
199–202, 261 |
Embargo notices |
153, 154 |
Evidence |
|
general provisions |
294 |
known user statements, sold vessel statements |
180 |
of speed |
293 |
295 |
|
Exemptions |
|
boating activities |
203–207 |
from requirements of Act |
260 |
57, 58 |
|
253–256 |
|
suspension during inquiries |
264 |
transitional provisions |
351, 353, 354, 359 |
Fees |
310–312 |
|
|
application of Act to voyages of |
9 |
Australian fishing vessels (defs) |
3, 95 |
declaration of |
7 |
definition |
3 |
registered persons (def.) |
3 |
regulations |
97 |
|
|
|
|
dangerous operation of |
87 |
declaration of |
7 |
definition |
3 |
unsafe vessels |
87 |
|
|
authorisation of persons to act as assistant harbour masters |
|
definition |
3 |
directions by |
232–236 |
duty to engage |
220 |
functions |
230 |
identity cards |
221, 344 |
|
|
Subject |
Section |
licences |
|
applications |
223 |
grant |
224 |
notification of conditions |
228 |
requirement for |
222 |
variation of conditions of |
225–227 |
licensed harbour masters (def.) |
3 |
obstruction, non-compliance with directions of |
237 |
powers (general) |
231 |
powers regarding |
|
amendment, revocation of directions |
235 |
carrying out of directions |
236 |
entry, removal of vessels |
233 |
written and oral directions |
232 |
protection from liability |
238 |
Safety Director's directions prevail |
234 |
Safety Director's powers |
258, Sch. 1 |
transitional provisions |
344–348 |
|
|
application of Act to voyages of |
9 |
approval for recreational use |
72 |
3 |
|
dangerous operation of |
87 |
declaration of |
7 |
definition |
3 |
directions prohibiting operation of |
155 |
licensing offences |
49–51 |
3 |
|
unsafe vessels |
87 |
unsuitable for recreational use |
8 |
See also Marine licences |
|
Improvement notices |
365 |
Infringement notices |
156, 158 |
Inspectors |
364 |
International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974 |
|
Inter-state voyages |
9, 95 |
Intra-state voyages |
9 |
Inquiries |
264 |
Investigations |
91, 363, 364 |
Licences See Marine licences |
|
Lights |
159, Sch. 1 |
Load lines |
86, Sch. 1 |
158 |
|
|
|
application |
82 |
conditions |
83 |
declaration of State waters requiring |
81 |
duration, issue |
83 |
|
|
Subject |
Section |
navigation of vessels without |
80 |
renewal |
84 |
transitional provisions |
355, 356 |
See also Certificates of competency |
|
|
|
definition |
3 |
liability |
238 |
local ports (def.) |
3 |
powers, duties |
|
activity exclusion zones |
208, 209 |
control of navigation in vicinity of works |
211, 212 |
declaration of exempt boating activities |
203, 204 |
emergency directions |
215 |
engagement of harbour masters |
220, 229 |
standards for navigation aids, dredging |
202 |
186, 193, 194, 196 |
|
recovery of costs from |
263 |
Magistrates' Court |
114, 368–372 |
Marine enforcement policy |
|
consultation in development, review |
281 |
content |
282 |
co-ordination, support of implementation |
280 |
development, maintenance, publication, review by Safety Director |
|
regard to be had |
283 |
|
|
definition |
3 |
3, 93, 94, 270 |
|
3, 156, 157 |
|
|
|
breach of conditions |
46–48, 59 |
cancellation |
91, 93, 171 |
conditions |
53–55 |
definition |
3 |
disqualification from holding |
60, 93, 171, 172 |
endorsements |
47, 55 |
exemptions |
|
licences issued outside Victoria |
57 |
58 |
|
53 |
|
grant |
53, 54 |
purposes |
45 |
renewal |
53, 54 |
54 |
|
review of decisions regarding |
288–290 |
suspension |
60, 91, 93, 171, 172 |
testing |
56 |
transitional provisions |
327–341, 368–372 |
unlicensed masters |
46 |
Subject |
Section |
See also Permissions |
|
Marine operations (def.) |
3 |
Marine safety |
|
elimination, reduction of risks |
23 |
inquiries into marine safety matters |
3, 264 |
marine safety equipment, design and construction activities |
|
3, 24, 28 |
|
marine safety work (def.) |
3 |
3, 30 |
|
principles |
|
accountability for managing safety risks |
16 |
effect of |
22 |
enforcement |
18 |
equity of use of Victorian waterways |
21 |
integrated risk management |
17 |
participation, consultation, involvement of all affected persons |
|
shared responsibility |
15 |
transparency in decision making |
19 |
3 |
|
|
|
application of Act to |
9 |
compliance with directions of |
32, 33 |
definition of master |
3 |
duties regarding |
|
activity exclusion zones |
210, 213 |
breach of conditions of registration |
37 |
certificates of competency |
74, 77–79 |
directions of harbour masters |
237 |
directions prohibiting operation of vessels |
155, 162 |
load lines |
86 |
80–84 |
|
253, 255, 256 |
|
93, 94 |
|
62, 63 |
|
67, 68 |
|
unregistered vessels |
37 |
unsafe vessels |
85, 87 |
use of pilots |
248 |
31 |
|
failure to assist people in distress |
91 |
liability |
257 |
not to be found guilty as owner |
101 |
3, 256 |
|
recovery of costs from |
263 |
Safety Director's powers |
258, Sch. 1 |
service of notices on |
110 |
See also Marine licences; Recreational vessels – Impoundment, immobilisation |
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
Minister |
|
powers regarding |
|
acquisition of land |
271 |
codes of practice |
272, 273, 275, 276, 278 |
declaration of waterway managers |
6 |
3, 300 |
|
National Standard for the Administration of Marine Safety |
|
Navigation |
|
control of in the vicinity of works |
211, 212 |
harbour masters' duties |
230, 232 |
obstructions to |
267, 268 |
port management bodies' duties |
24 |
Safety Director's powers |
184, 258, 262, 263, 268, Sch. 1 |
waterway managers' functions |
216 |
|
|
acquisition of land for |
271 |
definition |
3 |
interference with |
302 |
provision, maintenance |
261 |
standards |
199–202 |
11 |
|
Offences |
|
adverse publicity orders |
173 |
by officers of bodies corporate |
285 |
by partnerships, unincorporated bodies, associations |
|
civil liability not affected by Parts 2.2–2.6 |
35 |
embargo notices |
153, 154 |
101 |
|
indictable offences |
24–30, 88, 302, 304 |
156, 157 |
|
place where committed |
291 |
regarding |
|
activity exclusion zones |
210 |
102 |
|
breach of licence conditions |
59 |
breach of registration conditions |
37 |
bribery |
304 |
certificates of competency |
73–76 |
contravention of regulations |
96 |
contravention of waterway rules |
197, 198 |
crews |
73, 74 |
dangerous operation of vessels |
87 |
declarations regarding boating activities |
207 |
design, manufacture, supply of marine safety equipment, vessels |
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
155 |
|
directions to move vessels |
92, 162 |
directions, notices regarding navigation |
213–215, 267 |
disclosure of information |
306 |
disqualified masters of recreational vessels |
60 |
distress signals |
90 |
embargo notices |
154 |
emergency directions |
215 |
endangering vessels or crews |
88 |
engagement of harbour masters |
220 |
failure to assist people in distress |
91 |
failure to state name, address, giving false name, address |
|
false, misleading information |
182 |
false statements, misrepresentation |
305 |
forfeiture orders |
119 |
forgery, fraudulent of documents, identification marks |
|
221, 222 |
|
interference with navigation aids |
302 |
lights |
159 |
load lines |
86 |
80 |
|
marine enforcement policy |
279 |
24, 28 |
|
30 |
|
non-compliance with conditions on use of recreational vessels |
|
obstruction, hindrance of authorised persons |
303 |
obstruction, hindrance of police |
115 |
obstruction, non-compliance with directions of harbour masters |
|
operation of recreational vessels |
32 |
operation of vessels |
269 |
owner onus offences |
180 |
25, 73 |
|
passengers on board vessels |
33 |
permission records |
170 |
239, 245–247 |
|
248, 249 |
|
port management bodies |
24 |
possession of marine licences |
61 |
recreational vessel licensing offences |
46–48, 52, 59–61 |
49–51 |
|
93, 94 |
|
62, 63 |
|
67, 68 |
|
sale, disposal of interests in recreational vessels subject to orders |
|
search and seizure warrants |
143 |
standards for dredging, navigation aids |
202 |
Subject |
Section |
suppliers of vessel operations |
29 |
surrender of recreational vessels |
107, 118, 119 |
tampering with vessels |
89 |
unlicensed masters |
46–52, 60 |
unregistered vessels |
37 |
unsafe vessels |
85, 87 |
25, 31 |
|
single charges for multiple contraventions |
34 |
summary jurisdiction in indictable offences |
298 |
Overseas voyages |
9, 95 |
Owner onus offences |
|
cancellation of acceptance of effective statements |
179 |
contravention of waterway rules as |
198 |
defences |
181 |
definitions |
175 |
effect of payment of penalty |
177 |
false, misleading statements |
182 |
liability of responsible person at time of offence |
176 |
proceedings against nominated persons |
180 |
purpose of Part 4.7 |
174 |
use of effective statements |
178 |
|
|
application of Act to |
9 |
definition |
3 |
duties regarding |
|
certificates of competency |
76 |
crews |
73 |
load lines |
86 |
removal of obstructions to navigation |
267 |
94 |
|
62–64, 66 |
|
67–69, 71 |
|
safety of vessels, marine safety equipment, operations |
|
service of notices |
110 |
surrender of vessels |
107, 118, 119 |
unregistered vessels |
37 |
unsafe vessels |
85, 87 |
use of commercial vessels recreationally |
69, 72 |
use of unlicensed masters |
52 |
liability of |
101 |
proof of ownership |
132 |
recovery of charges, expenses from |
236, 263 |
recovery of costs, loss, damages from |
257, 268 |
third party protection from forfeiture orders |
133 |
Partnerships, unincorporated associations |
286 |
Passengers |
33, Sch. 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
|
|
cancellation, suspension, conditions |
166, 307 |
definitions |
3, 163 |
disciplinary action against holders of |
164, 165 |
disqualification from applying for |
166 |
effect of suspension |
169 |
immediate suspension notices |
168 |
return of records |
170 |
review of decisions regarding |
288–290 |
service of disciplinary notices on holders of |
167 |
suspension during inquiries |
264 |
variation |
307 |
Personal watercraft (def.) |
3 |
|
|
compliance with safety standards |
247 |
definition |
3 |
liability |
257 |
pilotage services (def.) |
3 |
records to be kept |
246 |
register |
244 |
registration |
|
applications |
240 |
certificates |
243 |
changes to information |
245 |
duration |
242 |
grant of |
241 |
Safety Director's powers |
258, Sch. 1 |
transitional provisons |
349, 350 |
unregistered providers |
239 |
See also Vessels |
|
|
|
acting without licence, exemption |
249 |
declaration of pilot required waters |
3, 250 |
definition |
3 |
exemptions |
|
applications |
253 |
effect of |
255 |
grant |
254 |
pilot exempt masters (def.) |
3 |
renewal |
256 |
failure to use services of |
248 |
liability |
257 |
licences |
251, 252 |
licensed pilot (def.) |
3 |
Safety Director's powers |
251, 252, 258, Sch. 1 |
transitional provisions |
319, 351–354 |
See also Permissions; Pilotage services providers |
|
|
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
Police |
|
obstruction, hindrance of police |
115 |
powers regarding |
|
arrest without warrant |
160 |
authorisation of persons to assist |
109 |
bringing of proceedings |
292 |
embargo notices |
154 |
impoundment, immobilisation of recreational vessels |
|
infringement notices |
156 |
moving, taking charge of vessels |
160, 161 |
prohibition on operation of vessels |
155, 269 |
release of recreational vessels |
113 |
requests for waterway rules |
186, 194 |
requirement to state name and address |
157 |
search and seizure warrants |
134, 137–139, 142 |
surrender of recreational vessels |
107 |
senior police officers |
103, 112, 113 |
Port management bodies |
|
definition |
3 |
liability |
238 |
powers, duties regarding |
|
activity exclusion zones |
208, 209 |
control of navigation in the vicinity of works |
211, 212 |
emergency directions |
215 |
exemptions for boating activities |
203, 204 |
safety of marine safety infrastructure operations |
|
standards for navigation aids, dredging |
202 |
186, 193, 194, 196 |
|
recovery of costs from |
263 |
3, 220, 229 |
|
Ports (def.) |
3 |
Prevention of Collisions Convention |
|
See Convention on the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea, 1972 |
|
Proceedings |
|
against nominated persons |
180 |
power to bring |
292 |
responsible agency for Crown |
287 |
Prohibition notices |
366 |
|
|
appeal rights |
114 |
application of Act to voyages of |
9 |
application of Part 4.2 |
104 |
dangerous operation of |
87 |
declaration of |
7 |
definition |
3 |
directions prohibiting operation of |
155 |
issue of embargo notices |
154 |
|
|
Subject |
Section |
licensing of masters of |
45 |
licensing offences |
46–48 |
masters' duties |
31 |
non-compliance with Australian Builders Plate Standard |
|
operators' duties |
32 |
registered persons (def.) |
3 |
3 |
|
unsafe vessels |
87 |
See also Recreational vessels – Impoundment, immobilisation; Recreational vessels – Registration |
|
Recreational vessels – Impoundment, immobilisation |
|
application for release |
114 |
application of proceeds of sale |
146, 151 |
compensation |
129 |
definitions |
103 |
directions regarding registration |
124–126 |
disposal orders |
144, 147–151 |
exercise of ownership rights |
132 |
forfeiture orders |
119, 120, 121, 123, 133, 145 |
hearing of applications for orders |
127 |
impoundment, immobilisation orders |
118, 120, 121 |
in addition to other penalties |
104 |
issue of notices of |
110, 111 |
liability for costs |
131 |
movement by police to impound, immobilise |
108, 130 |
movement of vessel, tampering with equipment |
115 |
obstruction, hindrance of police |
115 |
orders by Chief Commissioner |
118 |
orders take effect |
129 |
payment of designated costs |
113, 114, 116, 117, 131 |
persons authorised to assist police |
109 |
police powers to seize, impound, immobilise |
105, 130 |
prohibition on sale, disposal of interests in vessels subject to orders |
|
protection of third party interests from forfeiture orders |
|
release, return of vessels |
112, 113, 116, 117 |
sale, disposal of vessels, items |
144, 145, 147–150 |
seizure |
106, 130 |
service of notice of application |
121 |
surrender |
107, 108, 118, 119 |
transfer of interests in vessels subject to orders |
122 |
variation of orders |
128 |
See also Search and seizure warrants |
|
|
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
Recreational vessels – Registration |
|
breach of conditions |
37 |
cancellation |
43, 44 |
conditions |
40, 41 |
directions not to transfer, register vessels |
124, 125 |
granting of |
39 |
name vessel registered in |
38 |
purpose |
36 |
register of registered vessels |
42 |
renewal |
39 |
suspension |
43, 126 |
transfer |
39 |
transitional provisions |
320–325 |
unregistered vessels |
37 |
Register of Pilotage Services Providers |
244, 350 |
Register of registered vessels |
42 |
|
|
Regulations |
|
effect of compliance with |
299 |
exemption from compliance with |
206 |
nationally agreed standards in |
300 |
power to make and matters provided for |
309, Sch. 2 |
regarding fees |
310–312 |
regarding international conventions |
96–99 |
savings and transitional |
315 |
300 |
|
Relevant marine safety laws (def.) |
3 |
|
|
Review |
|
by senior police officers |
112 |
by VCAT |
290 |
internal review |
289, 367 |
marine enforcement policy |
279, 281 |
reviewable decisions (def.) |
288 |
|
|
|
|
Safety Convention |
|
|
|
declaration as waterway manager |
6 |
definition |
3 |
functions |
258 |
powers (general) |
259, Sch. 1 |
powers regarding |
|
activity exclusion zones |
208, 209 |
adverse publicity orders |
173 |
approval of commercially operated vessels for recreational use |
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
certificates of competency |
78, 79 |
codes of practice for waterway management |
219 |
declaration of vessels |
7 |
declarations regarding commercially operated vehicles unsuitable for recreational use |
|
detention of unsafe vessels |
85 |
directions regarding navigation |
211, 212 |
directions to harbour masters |
235 |
disciplinary action |
164–168 |
disclosure of information |
306 |
emergency directions |
215 |
entry, removal of vessels |
233 |
exemptions for boating activities |
203, 204 |
exemptions from requirements of Act |
260 |
fittings, materials, appliances, apparatus |
100 |
harbour master licences, identity cards |
221, 223–228 |
81–83 |
|
marine enforcement policy |
279–281 |
199–201, 261, 266 |
|
obstruction to navigation |
262, 268 |
permission records |
170, 307 |
253, 254 |
|
recovery of costs |
263 |
review |
289 |
standards for dredging |
199–201 |
184–188, 190–195 |
|
transitional provisions |
357–359, 367, 374 |
See also Marine licences; Pilotage services providers; Recreational vessels – Registration; Vessels |
|
Safety education |
312 |
Search and seizure warrants |
|
announcement before entry |
137 |
application of Magistrates' Court Act 1989 |
140 |
applications for |
134 |
copies given to occupier |
138 |
expiry |
141 |
issue |
135 |
obstruction, hindrance of person executing |
143 |
record of proceedings |
136 |
report on execution |
142 |
use of assistants to execute |
139 |
90 |
|
Service of documents |
308 |
Service of notices |
|
disciplinary notices |
167 |
disposal orders |
148, 152 |
effective statements |
178 |
embargo notices |
154 |
|
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
impoundment, immobilisation orders, forfeiture orders |
|
unsafe vessels |
85 |
Signals |
90, Schs 1, 2 |
Speed |
|
evidentiary provisions |
293 |
|
|
activity exclusion zones |
208–210 |
definition |
3 |
3, 186 |
|
works carried out on, under |
211, 212 |
3, 26, 27, 102 |
|
Survey of vessels |
65, 362 |
3, 7, 9 |
|
3, 154–157 |
|
3, 295, 300 |
|
|
|
VCAT |
265, 290 |
|
|
Act presumed to apply to |
296 |
acts tending to endanger |
88 |
application of Act to voyages of |
9 |
close quarters situations (def.) |
4 |
connection with Victoria |
9 |
dangerous operation of |
87 |
declaration of |
7 |
definition |
3 |
design, manufacture, supply |
26 |
detention |
85 |
distress signals |
90 |
duties of suppliers to owners of |
29 |
exemptions from requirements of Act |
260 |
harbour masters' powers |
232–236 |
load lines |
86, Schs 1, 2 |
masters' duties, liability |
37 |
operate (def.) |
3 |
passengers' duties |
33 |
police powers |
160, 161 |
prohibition on operation of |
269 |
270 |
|
|
|
applications |
64 |
issue |
65 |
offences |
62, 63 |
renewal |
66 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Subject |
Section |
|
|
application |
69 |
issue |
70 |
offences |
67, 68 |
72 |
|
renewal |
71 |
Safety Director's powers |
258, Sch. 1 |
seizure, sale of for unpaid orders |
297 |
speed (evidentiary provisions) |
293 |
survey |
65 |
tampering with |
89 |
transitional provisions |
318, 326, 362 |
unsafe vessels |
5, 85 |
3 |
|
3, 25 |
|
See also Fishing vessels; Government vessels; |
|
|
|
3, 220 |
|
3, 285, 286 |
|
|
|
codes of practice for waterway management |
219 |
declaration |
6 |
definition |
3 |
fees |
311 |
functions, powers (general) |
216 |
indemnity |
218 |
liability |
238 |
powers, duties regarding |
|
activity exclusion zones |
208, 209 |
authorisation of assistant harbour masters |
229 |
delegation |
217 |
emergency directions |
215 |
engagement of licensed harbour masters |
220 |
exemptions regarding boating activities |
203, 204 |
navigation in vicinity of works |
211, 212 |
request for waterway rules |
186, 193, 194, 196 |
standards for navigation aids, dredging |
202 |
recovery of costs from |
263 |
regulations |
311 |
transitional provisions |
317, 373 |
|
|
commencement |
189 |
consequential rules |
185 |
contravention |
197, 198, 207 |
definitions |
183 |
exemptions |
203, 205–207 |
making, matters to be considered |
184, 187 |
|
|
Subject |
Section |
on request, or on Safety Director's initiative |
186 |
publication |
190 |
reasons for making, not making |
188 |
requests for making, consultation requirements |
193–196 |
transitional provisions |
342 |
urgent safety rules |
183, 191, 192 |