Gualberto J De La Llana Presiding Judge, Branch II of the City Court of Olongapo, Estanislao l Cesa, JR , Fidela Y Vargas, Benjamin C Escolango, Juanito C Atienza, Manuel Reyes Rosapapan, JR , Virgilio E Acierto, and Porfirio Aguillon Aguila v Manuel Alba, Minister of Budget, Francisco Tantuico, Chairman, Commission on Audit, and Ricardo Puno, Minister of Justice

[1982] PHSC 94

Supreme Court of the Philippines

Philippines

12th March, 1982

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Judiciary Act (Cth)	s67

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court †	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
28 Cleveland State Law Review 301	28 Cleveland State Law Review 301	Cleveland State Law Review	United States		HeinOnline / LexisNexis	1
Merchant Service Guild of Australasia v The Commonwealth Steam-Ship Owners Association	[1905] CthArbRp 1; 1 CAR 1	Commonwealth Arbitration Reports	Australia - Commonwealth	12 Dec 1905	AustLII	16
Fortun v Labang	(1981) 104 SCRA 607	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1981		17
Pamil v Teleron	(1978) 86 SCRA 413	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1978		6
(1974) 55 Scra 34	(1974) 55 SCRA 34	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1974		3
(1974) 58 Scra 711	(1974) 58 SCRA 711	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1974		3
(1973) 53 Scra 156	(1973) 53 SCRA 156	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1973		1
Martinez v Morfe	(1972) 44 SCRA 22	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1972		5
(1970) 35 Scra 431	(1970) 35 SCRA 431	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1970		1
(1970) 31 Scra 278	(1970) 31 SCRA 278	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1970		4
(1969) 29 Scra 580	(1969) 29 SCRA 580	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1969		8
Arao v Luspo	(1967) 20 SCRA 722	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1967		9
Maza v Ochave	(1967) 20 SCRA 142	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1967		8
Abanilla, v Ticao,	(1966) 17 SCRA 652	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1966		6
Ocampo, v Duque	(1966) 16 SCRA 962	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1966		9
Cuneta v Court of Appeals	1961 1 SCRA 663; 111 Phil 249	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1961		8
Urgelio v Osmena, Jr	9 SCRA 317	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		7
Santos v Mallare	87 Phil 289; 13 SCRA 591	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		50
30 Scra 67	30 SCRA 67	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		3
People vs Prieto, Sr	84 SCRA 198	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		3
People v Kayanan	83 SCRA 437	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		12
90 Scra 629	90 SCRA 629	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		1
Agustin v Edu	88 SCRA 195	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		6
Morfe v Mutuc	22 SCRA 424; 130 Phil 415	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		50
Aquino v Commission on Elections	62 SCRA 275	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		36
Baldoz v Office of the President	78 SCRA 354	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		3
Agricultural Credit and Cooperative Financing Administration	18 SCRA 183	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		37
Llanto v Dimaporo	16 SCRA 599	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		20
Guevarra vs Inocentes	16 SCRA 379	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		10
Constitution (Uy v Genato	57 SCRA 123	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		10
Cruz v Primicias	23 SCRA 998	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		19
De la Llana v Comelec	80 SCRA 525	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1905		5
Fish, William Howard Taft and Charles Evan Hughes	[1975] Supreme Court Review 123	Supreme Court Review	United States	circa 1975		1
Roschen v Ward	279 US 337; 73 L Ed 722; 49 SCt 336	United States Supreme Court	United States	22 Apr 1929	WorldLII	51
Springer v Philippine Islands	277 US 189; 72 L Ed 845; 48 SCt 480	United States Supreme Court	United States	14 May 1928	WorldLII	70
Myles Salt Co v Board of Comm'rs of Iberia and St Mary Drainage Dist	239 US 478; 60 L Ed 392; 36 SCt 204	United States Supreme Court	United States	10 Jan 1916	WorldLII	22
Lochner v New York	198 US 45; 49 L Ed 937; 3 Ann Cas 1133; 3 A & E Ann Cas 1133; 25 SCt 539; 49 L Ed 2d 937	United States Supreme Court	United States	17 Apr 1905	WorldLII	280
Missouri, K & T R Co v May	194 US 267; 48 L Ed 971; 24 SCt 638	United States Supreme Court	United States	2 May 1904	WorldLII	52
Holy Trinity Church v United States	143 US 461; 143 US 457; 36 L Ed 226; 12 SCt 511	United States Supreme Court	United States	29 Feb 1892	WorldLII	286
Marbury v Madison	5 US 137; 1 Cranch 137; 2 L Ed 135; 2 L Ed 60; 6 Pet 241	United States Supreme Court	United States	1 Feb 1803	WorldLII	1030
79 Yale Law Journal 1	79 Yale Law Journal 1	Yale Law Journal	United States	circa 1916	HeinOnline / Westlaw	1
Ocampo v Duque	123 Phil 842		Philippines	circa 1916		2
41 Phil 330	41 Phil 330		Philippines	circa 1916		1
People v Crane	214 NY 154; 108 NE 427		United States - New York	circa 1916		7
Government of the Philippine Islands v Springer	50 Phil 259		Philippines	circa 1916		17
32 So 2	32 So 2		United States	circa 1916		1
Briones v Osmena	104 Phil 588		Philippines	circa 1916		14
People v Linsangan	62 Phil 646		Philippines	circa 1916		7
Manalang v Quitoriano	94 Phil 903		Philippines	circa 1916		23
People v Vera	65 Phil 56		Philippines	circa 1916		160
Gacho v Osme ñ a Jr	103 Phil 837		Philippines	circa 1916		9
People v Vera	67 Phil 56		Philippines	circa 1916		1
Borromeo vs Mariano	41 Phil 322		Philippines	circa 1916		31
31 CJS 810	31 CJS 810		United States	circa 1916		1
Arnault v Pecson	87 Phil 418		Philippines	circa 1916		6
Perkins v Corbin	6 Am Rep 698; 45 Ala 103		United States	circa 1916		1
Angara v Electoral Commission	63 Phil 139		Philippines	circa 1916		101
Planas v Gil	67 Phil 62		Philippines	circa 1916		46
Brown v Russell	166 Mass 14; 43 NE 1005; 32 LRA 253		United States - Massachusetts	circa 1916		5
Rodriguez v Montinola	94 Phil 964		Philippines	circa 1916		15
2 Lea 316	2 Lea 316		United States - Tennessee	circa 1916		1
Llanto v Dimaporo	123 Phil 413		Philippines	circa 1916		1
199 Mass 47; 85 Ne 182; 127 Asr 468	199 Mass 47; 85 NE 182; 127 ASR 468		United States - Massachusetts	circa 1916		2
Manila Electric Co v Pasay Transportation Co	57 Phil 600		Philippines	circa 1916		19
Segovia v Noel	47 Phil 543		Philippines	circa 1916		14
Mc Culley vs State	46 LRA 567		United States	circa 1916		2
106 Pac 695	106 Pac 695		United States	circa 1916		2
Alipio v Rodriguez	119 Phil 59		Philippines	circa 1916		1
Tanada v Cuenco	103 Phil 1051		Philippines			50
Guillergan v Ganzon	123 Phil 1102		Philippines	circa 1916		1
Thomas v Gunter	54 So 283; 170 Ala 165		United States	circa 1916		1
Brillo vs Enage	94 Phil 732		Philippines	circa 1916		4
10 Sec 23	10 SEC 23		United States	circa 1916		3
Castro v Sagales	94 Phil 208		Philippines	circa 1916		18
citing	42 Am Jur 881		United States	circa 1916		2
Zandueta vs De la Costa	66 Phil 615		Philippines	circa 1916		17
Briones v Osme ñ a Jr	105 Phil 588		Philippines	circa 1916		1
Facundo v Hon Pabalan	114 Phil 307		Philippines	circa 1916		2

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback