Gualberto J De La Llana Presiding Judge, Branch II of the City Court of Olongapo, Estanislao l Cesa, JR , Fidela Y Vargas, Benjamin C Escolango, Juanito C Atienza, Manuel Reyes Rosapapan, JR , Virgilio E Acierto, and Porfirio Aguillon Aguila v Manuel Alba, Minister of Budget, Francisco Tantuico, Chairman, Commission on Audit, and Ricardo Puno, Minister of Justice

[1982] PHSC 94

Supreme Court of the Philippines

Philippines

12th March, 1982

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Judiciary Act (Cth)	s67

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text †	Citation Index
Merchant Service Guild of Australasia v The Commonwealth Steam-Ship Owners Association	[1905] CthArbRp 1; 1 CAR 1	Commonwealth Arbitration Reports	Australia - Commonwealth	12 Dec 1905	AustLII	16
28 Cleveland State Law Review 301	28 Cleveland State Law Review 301	Cleveland State Law Review	United States	circa 1905	HeinOnline / LexisNexis	1
79 Yale Law Journal 1	79 Yale Law Journal 1	Yale Law Journal	United States	circa 1905	HeinOnline / Westlaw	1
Roschen v Ward	279 US 337; 73 L Ed 722; 49 SCt 336	United States Supreme Court	United States	22 Apr 1929	WorldLII	51
Springer v Philippine Islands	277 US 189; 72 L Ed 845; 48 SCt 480	United States Supreme Court	United States	14 May 1928	WorldLII	70
Myles Salt Co v Board of Comm'rs of Iberia and St Mary Drainage Dist	239 US 478; 60 L Ed 392; 36 SCt 204	United States Supreme Court	United States	10 Jan 1916	WorldLII	22
Lochner v New York	198 US 45; 49 L Ed 937; 3 Ann Cas 1133; 3 A & E Ann Cas 1133; 25 SCt 539; 49 L Ed 2d 937	United States Supreme Court	United States	17 Apr 1905	WorldLII	280
Missouri, K & T R Co v May	194 US 267; 48 L Ed 971; 24 SCt 638	United States Supreme Court	United States	2 May 1904	WorldLII	52
Holy Trinity Church v United States	143 US 461; 143 US 457; 36 L Ed 226; 12 SCt 511	United States Supreme Court	United States	29 Feb 1892	WorldLII	286
Marbury v Madison	5 US 137; 1 Cranch 137; 2 L Ed 135; 2 L Ed 60; 6 Pet 241	United States Supreme Court	United States	1 Feb 1803	WorldLII	1031
Facundo v Hon Pabalan	114 Phil 307		Philippines	circa 1916		2
106 Pac 695	106 Pac 695		United States	circa 1916		2
Llanto v Dimaporo	123 Phil 413		Philippines	circa 1916		1
Llanto v Dimaporo	16 SCRA 599	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			20
Guillergan v Ganzon	123 Phil 1102		Philippines			1
30 Scra 67	30 SCRA 67	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			3
31 CJS 810	31 CJS 810		United States			1
32 So 2	32 So 2		United States			1
10 Sec 23	10 SEC 23		United States			3
Manalang v Quitoriano	94 Phil 903		Philippines			23
Manila Electric Co v Pasay Transportation Co	57 Phil 600		Philippines	circa 1916		19
(1974) 58 Scra 711	(1974) 58 SCRA 711	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1974		3
Agricultural Credit and Cooperative Financing Administration	18 SCRA 183	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			37
Agustin v Edu	88 SCRA 195	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			6
Alipio v Rodriguez	119 Phil 59		Philippines			1
Angara v Electoral Commission	63 Phil 139		Philippines			101
Martinez v Morfe	(1972) 44 SCRA 22	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1972		5
Maza v Ochave	(1967) 20 SCRA 142	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1967		8
Mc Culley vs State	46 LRA 567		United States			2
(1974) 55 Scra 34	(1974) 55 SCRA 34	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1974		3
Briones v Osmena	104 Phil 588		Philippines			14
(1973) 53 Scra 156	(1973) 53 SCRA 156	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1973		1
Castro v Sagales	94 Phil 208		Philippines			18
Morfe v Mutuc	22 SCRA 424; 130 Phil 415	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			50
Cruz v Primicias	23 SCRA 998	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
(1970) 35 Scra 431	(1970) 35 SCRA 431	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1970		1
De la Llana v Comelec	80 SCRA 525	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			5
Ocampo v Duque	123 Phil 842		Philippines			2
Fish, William Howard Taft and Charles Evan Hughes	[1975] Supreme Court Review 123	Supreme Court Review	United States	circa 1975		1
Ocampo, v Duque	(1966) 16 SCRA 962	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1966		9
Gacho v Osme ñ a Jr	103 Phil 837		Philippines	circa 1975		9
Pamil v Teleron	(1978) 86 SCRA 413	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1978		6
Guevarra vs Inocentes	16 SCRA 379	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			10
People v Crane	214 NY 154; 108 NE 427		United States - New York			7
199 Mass 47; 85 Ne 182; 127 Asr 468	199 Mass 47; 85 NE 182; 127 ASR 468		United States - Massachusetts	circa 1975		2
People v Kayanan	83 SCRA 437	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1975		12
Abanilla, v Ticao,	(1966) 17 SCRA 652	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1966		6
People v Linsangan	62 Phil 646		Philippines	circa 1975		7
Arao v Luspo	(1967) 20 SCRA 722	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1967		9
People v Vera	65 Phil 56		Philippines	circa 1975		160
Baldoz v Office of the President	78 SCRA 354	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1975		3
People v Vera	67 Phil 56		Philippines	circa 1975		1
Brillo vs Enage	94 Phil 732		Philippines	circa 1975		4
People vs Prieto, Sr	84 SCRA 198	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1975		3
Brown v Russell	166 Mass 14; 43 NE 1005; 32 LRA 253		United States - Massachusetts	circa 1975		5
Perkins v Corbin	6 Am Rep 698; 45 Ala 103		United States	circa 1975		1
Cuneta v Court of Appeals	1961 1 SCRA 663; 111 Phil 249	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1961		8
Planas v Gil	67 Phil 62		Philippines	circa 1975		46
Fortun v Labang	(1981) 104 SCRA 607	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1981		17
Rodriguez v Montinola	94 Phil 964		Philippines	circa 1975		15
(1970) 31 Scra 278	(1970) 31 SCRA 278	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1970		4
90 Scra 629	90 SCRA 629	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1975		1
Santos v Mallare	87 Phil 289; 13 SCRA 591	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1975		50
Arnault v Pecson	87 Phil 418		Philippines	circa 1975		6
Segovia v Noel	47 Phil 543		Philippines	circa 1975		14
Briones v Osme ñ a Jr	105 Phil 588		Philippines	circa 1975		1
(1969) 29 Scra 580	(1969) 29 SCRA 580	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1969		8
2 Lea 316	2 Lea 316		United States - Tennessee	circa 1975		1
Tanada v Cuenco	103 Phil 1051		Philippines	circa 1975		50
41 Phil 330	41 Phil 330		Philippines	circa 1975		1
Thomas v Gunter	54 So 283; 170 Ala 165		United States	circa 1975		1
Borromeo vs Mariano	41 Phil 322		Philippines	circa 1975		31
Urgelio v Osmena, Jr	9 SCRA 317	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1975		7
Government of the Philippine Islands v Springer	50 Phil 259		Philippines			17
citing	42 Am Jur 881		United States			2
Zandueta vs De la Costa	66 Phil 615		Philippines			17
Aquino v Commission on Elections	62 SCRA 275	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			36
Constitution (Uy v Genato	57 SCRA 123	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			10

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback